Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
81 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
It Was NOT The Last Supper... (Original Post) ._. Jul 2024 OP
"The headless woman was Marie Antoinette. She ruled over France and Dave Bowman Jul 2024 #1
She did not rule over France. LisaM Jul 2024 #17
She was married to the king, Louis XVI, and was Queen, and therefore was also a ruler over France. BComplex Jul 2024 #30
I know who she was, I have multiple biographies of her. LisaM Jul 2024 #37
So do I. BComplex Jul 2024 #38
Yes, we will. LisaM Jul 2024 #39
Not true, it was a mob that went crazy, it was a violent mob, just like the one on January 6, 2021 who dirtied the Escurumbele Jul 2024 #50
A mob that was riled up by the bourgeois who were trying to convert their wealth into political power. TheBlackAdder Jul 2024 #62
Marie Antionette was quenen consort of France. Progressive dog Jul 2024 #66
And also Louis XVI helped the Americans during the Polly Hennessey Jul 2024 #61
This is a topic I have tried to not get into but, Putin, Maduro, Kim Jun Un, and other dictators have Escurumbele Jul 2024 #49
Also, it was not the Last Supper. It was a depiction of an ancient Greek Bacchanal... LetMyPeopleVote Jul 2024 #59
Except that soldierant Jul 2024 #75
Thank you! hatrack Jul 2024 #2
Or why learn when you can rant and complain in ignorance???? TNNurse Jul 2024 #7
Cool Joinfortmill Jul 2024 #3
I've been giving Jesus MAGAts crap by posting a pic of King James and saying he would fit right in. brewens Jul 2024 #4
republicans have been juicing The Lie about this BoRaGard Jul 2024 #5
And their orange jesus.... rubbersole Jul 2024 #14
Also the god of theater. nt Susan Calvin Jul 2024 #6
thank you. love the last part. or mind your own beeswax. AllaN01Bear Jul 2024 #8
The myth of Farmer-Rick Jul 2024 #9
As did the "myth" of every other religion and culture. whathehell Jul 2024 #19
With The Added Twist, Sir The Magistrate Jul 2024 #28
Thank you. Was wondering about the whole horse thing. GoCubsGo Jul 2024 #10
The French have a long history of working with and adoring all things equestrian. The allegorical oracle Jul 2024 #16
Someone at NBC actually explained something?? dickthegrouch Jul 2024 #70
"Never let an opportunity to be offended by something pass you by." Buns_of_Fire Jul 2024 #11
Microphone drops! K&R Emile Jul 2024 #12
And even if it were, it would be nothing new . . . hatrack Jul 2024 #13
Yesterday I spent some time searching for that Latin. Arne Jul 2024 #29
I have zero interest in the Olympics but now I wish I had watched this opening ceremony!!! Siwsan Jul 2024 #15
It definitely evoked a PAINTING of the Last Supper. LisaM Jul 2024 #18
Ever wonder why everyone is sitting on the same side of the table ? eppur_se_muova Jul 2024 #22
Because Leonardo was on the other side of the table painting them, Duh! AZSkiffyGeek Jul 2024 #35
He was Painter to the Court of Christ. yorkster Jul 2024 #41
This reminds me of an old joke. Mr.Bill Jul 2024 #40
Explained... JoseBalow Jul 2024 #51
Every theater person knows... forgotmylogin Jul 2024 #45
I liked Mel Brooks version in History of the World lonely bird Jul 2024 #58
Completely wrong FreeState Jul 2024 #63
That is priceless wendyb-NC Jul 2024 #20
Xns, magats, and worst of all, magat "Xns" so quick to get butt hurt. Snowflake mofos always have to make it about them Comfortably_Numb Jul 2024 #21
Ignorant fool should malaise Jul 2024 #23
Ha! Well, frankly..I'll just be upset and speak my mind and do my best to find ... chouchou Jul 2024 #24
my friend pointed out the hypocrites are CINOs...yes they are NoSheep Jul 2024 #25
then why the apologies? Kali Jul 2024 #26
"The Last Supper" isn't the last supper, either. Iggo Jul 2024 #27
"If you weren't so busy trying to end the Dept of Education, you might know this". Bingo. . . .nt Bernardo de La Paz Jul 2024 #31
YEAH. calimary Jul 2024 #72
Thank you Lady Francis! liberalla Jul 2024 #32
Hell Yeah!!! calimary Jul 2024 #73
Whoa, that was awesome! Last part really hits home. ananda Jul 2024 #33
This was served on a platter to a tRumpy Christian relative.........by someone else joanbarnes Jul 2024 #34
Dear Republicans, dawg Jul 2024 #36
K&R. Mythvision Podcast (Derek LAMBERT) on YouTube provides tons of this info UTUSN Jul 2024 #42
Ignorance is the rock Mblaze Jul 2024 #43
More precisely, imo, belligerent ignorance. Dark n Stormy Knight Jul 2024 #44
It sounds right to me. Mblaze Jul 2024 #68
so what? poozwah Jul 2024 #46
It does show you where MAGA lostie mindsets are gulliver Jul 2024 #47
Typical American conservatives BrianTheEVGuy Jul 2024 #48
Ugly Americans. Deuxcents Jul 2024 #52
Body and soul. NT BrianTheEVGuy Jul 2024 #54
The real reason they're upset: piddyprints Jul 2024 #53
Some Christians desperately need to get educated. SleeplessinSoCal Jul 2024 #55
France has always been secular and anti-clericalism (i.e. opposed to religious authority) tornado34jh Jul 2024 #56
Conspiracy theorist assholes SpankMe Jul 2024 #57
It wasn't the last supper. It was the feast of Dionysus, LetMyPeopleVote Jul 2024 #60
For them, it pays to be ignorant DENVERPOPS Jul 2024 #64
Don Jr is one of the outraged "Xtians" Hassler Jul 2024 #65
They just want to find something to bitch about France Dem4life1234 Jul 2024 #67
This message was self-deleted by its author B.See Jul 2024 #76
most who claim to be "christian" raising2moredems Jul 2024 #69
Religion.... purr-rat beauty Jul 2024 #71
too bad prodigitalson Jul 2024 #74
Dem said: "They just want to find something to bitch about France" B.See Jul 2024 #77
Fake Christians anniebelle Jul 2024 #78
They're not fake Zoomie1986 Jul 2024 #79
Care To Elaborate? ProfessorGAC Jul 2024 #80
Just because they're bad Xians doesn't mean they're fake. Iggo Jul 2024 #81

Dave Bowman

(5,531 posts)
1. "The headless woman was Marie Antoinette. She ruled over France and
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 09:51 AM
Jul 2024

was found guilty of treason, conspiracy, and stealing from the country."

So many things in common with Lardo Loco.

LisaM

(29,301 posts)
17. She did not rule over France.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:47 AM
Jul 2024

That was Louis XVI. I really dislike when memes have these errors. There is no point, especially when you're scolding people for being uneducated.

BComplex

(9,498 posts)
30. She was married to the king, Louis XVI, and was Queen, and therefore was also a ruler over France.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:42 AM
Jul 2024

They didn't like how she ruled along side her husband. That's why they had her beheaded, along with him.

Queens are also considered rulers in most of those situations.

LisaM

(29,301 posts)
37. I know who she was, I have multiple biographies of her.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 12:19 PM
Jul 2024

She was not the monarch, and she didn't rule over all of France.

BComplex

(9,498 posts)
38. So do I.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 12:22 PM
Jul 2024

We'll just have to disagree on how things were perceived in France at the time.

LisaM

(29,301 posts)
39. Yes, we will.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 12:24 PM
Jul 2024

I find that meme terribly annoying and misleading. It's like saying Anne Boleyn ruled England.

Escurumbele

(3,840 posts)
50. Not true, it was a mob that went crazy, it was a violent mob, just like the one on January 6, 2021 who dirtied the
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 02:06 PM
Jul 2024

walls of the capitol with their own crap, and had Pence, or any politicians, come out, they would have hanged them, or killed them in any way they could.

There is a very interesting book, which I gave away and now I am trying to find it but cannot remember the name, tough search, but it talks about mobs and the effect they have on people who some have led a life of peace, have been volunteers at their church, helping anyone they can, but while being part of a mob become crazy like everyone else and end up committing crimes they never thought they would or could, and that is why Marie Antoinette was killed, the mob wanted blood.

TheBlackAdder

(29,603 posts)
62. A mob that was riled up by the bourgeois who were trying to convert their wealth into political power.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 04:57 PM
Jul 2024

Last edited Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:30 PM - Edit history (1)

These nouveau riche assholes did not know how to run a government, just to destroy it.
Their tinkering plunged France into 100 years of chaos and severely weakened the country.

Much like today's Elon Musk, Peter Thiel and others. Wealthy and politically ignorant fucks!

All they know how to do is destroy government, not to build upon the greatness, acting as stewards for the future.

Political and government changes must be gradual and tested. They can't be sudden whims or untested plans.
Notice how there is not one functioning government based on Libertarian principles. Two were tried and both failed.
There is a reason for that. Libertarianism is a flawed mentality and a perverted non-viable political principle.

Progressive dog

(7,501 posts)
66. Marie Antionette was quenen consort of France.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 08:07 PM
Jul 2024

She was wife of the king, she did not rule. She was the king's companion.

Escurumbele

(3,840 posts)
49. This is a topic I have tried to not get into but, Putin, Maduro, Kim Jun Un, and other dictators have
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 02:00 PM
Jul 2024

also made sham trials to accuse people of wrongdoing which they obviously did not do, to prosecute them in many different forms, the guillotine was the preferred choice at the time in France. To understand the "French Revolution" one must read extensively what that revolution was about, but that is not the case.

The Olympic show had very little to do with the games, the choreographer obviously wanted to make a point about LGBTQ which does not have a place in the Olympics. I am all for freedom of speech, for art, and for people being happy doing the things that make them happy, but respecting others is part of allowing people to be happy.

The skit where this young people meet at the library and then decide to have a threesome is nothing about love, they just met, all they wanted to do was to have sex. How does that equate with the Olympics?

I am sure many here, and I know it because I have read some of the posts, will disagree with me, which is fine, but the themes that were chosen for the opening were wrong, lacked decency and many had nothing to do with athletics. The Olympics is about celebrating Athleticism, not sex.

If Christians (I am not one by the way) were offended, or if anyone was offended (plenty did) then you have not done your job, even if the reference was about something else which by the way, the original painting does not have transsexual people in it.

LetMyPeopleVote

(166,964 posts)
59. Also, it was not the Last Supper. It was a depiction of an ancient Greek Bacchanal...
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 03:30 PM
Jul 2024


Appropriated from another post.
Dear friends,
The headless woman was Marie Antoinette. She ruled over France and was found guilty of treason, conspiracy, and stealing from the country.

Also, it was not the Last Supper. It was a depiction of an ancient Greek Bacchanal… because, you know, the Olympics are ancient and Greek. Surprise!

And if you didn’t know, a Bacchanalia is an uncontrollably promiscuous, extravagant, and loud party. The parties often spanned several days which honored the god of wine, Bacchus (the blue guy covered in grape vine). He is also known as Dionysus, the Greek god of fertility, later known as the god of wine and pleasure.

And finally, it was not Death on a pale horse. It was Sequana, Goddess of the Seine, the River in which the boat precession took place. She was meant to be the representation of the Olympic spirit and of Sequana.

If some of you weren’t so busy trying to end the Dept. of Education, you might know this.

Loosen the clutch on your pearls and get your panties pulled out of your A** 😉

Yours truly,
Lady Francis

soldierant

(8,774 posts)
75. Except that
Mon Jul 29, 2024, 12:45 AM
Jul 2024

she was most likely innocent of all of that It was misogyny that did her in

Interestiglly,she is one of the few people in that time period that we can be reasonably certain was not a racist. She wanted and tried to appoint Joseph de Boulogne, Chevalier Saint George, as the director of the Paris Opera. Unfortunately,a bunch of divas complained to her that they would not be directed by a "mulatto." You can't run an opera house with o divas, so it was either give in or lose opera entirely. He did remain a close friend of hers.

hatrack

(63,128 posts)
2. Thank you!
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 09:56 AM
Jul 2024

I guess when everything is All Jesus All The Time in the Church Of I'M SO PERSECUTED!! it's hard to make room in one's tiny mind for the classical culture which had existed for centuries before The Dude Himself even arrived.

 

brewens

(15,359 posts)
4. I've been giving Jesus MAGAts crap by posting a pic of King James and saying he would fit right in.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 09:58 AM
Jul 2024

Imagine portraying one of ol' Jimbo's parties without casting a few drag queens! Not a chance. LOL

BoRaGard

(6,564 posts)
5. republicans have been juicing The Lie about this
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:00 AM
Jul 2024

just like they juice other lies.

They are the Most Fake christians of all time.

Farmer-Rick

(11,887 posts)
9. The myth of
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:08 AM
Jul 2024

Christianity did steal a lot of iconic symbols, tableaux and ideas from the religious myths that came before it.




whathehell

(30,218 posts)
19. As did the "myth" of every other religion and culture.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:00 AM
Jul 2024

No man (woman, religion, culture) is an island.

The Magistrate

(96,043 posts)
28. With The Added Twist, Sir
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:26 AM
Jul 2024

Of claiming the pre-existing traditions they took over had all along been demonic counterfeits of the Christian practices to come....

These are people who live in a deeply weird world.

GoCubsGo

(34,116 posts)
10. Thank you. Was wondering about the whole horse thing.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:14 AM
Jul 2024

I wasn't aware of Sequana, and didn't catch any sort of explanation of it when I was watching. That's not to say there was one. I had assumed the whole Dionysus thing was just people out having a good time, minus the whole ancient Greece angle. "The Last Supper" never even occurred to me. It actually struck me more as the judge panel on a TV game show, like "The Voice" or "The Masked Singer."

allegorical oracle

(5,433 posts)
16. The French have a long history of working with and adoring all things equestrian. The
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:43 AM
Jul 2024

Sequana episode was explained during opening ceremony. The French long ago developed an entire horse training regimen called Haute Ecole or High School. The dressage portion of the Games is based in that training. Once a horse and rider have developed those skills they are equipped for battle or pleasure.

dickthegrouch

(4,087 posts)
70. Someone at NBC actually explained something??
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:50 PM
Jul 2024

Jeez, they’ll be showing athletes from other countries next.

(just about)

Buns_of_Fire

(18,618 posts)
11. "Never let an opportunity to be offended by something pass you by."
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:15 AM
Jul 2024

I think that's one of the New Commandments (King Trump Edition).

hatrack

(63,128 posts)
13. And even if it were, it would be nothing new . . .
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:24 AM
Jul 2024

In the relatively liberal and tolerant culture of medieval Europe, learned persons produced tremendous diversity in written texts. Just as classical Arabic culture produced raucous satire, medieval European culture produced bizarre animal stories providing vitally important teaching, vigorous works of men’s sexed protest, heartwarming stories of husbands’ loving concern for their wives, and many other texts scarcely conceivable today. Benefiting from medieval freedom of speech, medieval authors further wrote outrageous parodies of sacred liturgy and even of women.

Medieval liturgical parodies centered on drinking and gambling. Celebrants in parodic liturgy honored Bacchus, the traditional Greco-Roman god of wine, and Decius and Dolium, invented gods of dice and the cask of wine, respectively. The celebrants are compulsively driven to drink and gamble to excess. As a result, they get miserably drunk, groan, and commonly lose their clothes from losing bets.

I confess to Almighty God, to blessed Mary ever Virgin, to blessed Michael the Archangel to blessed John the Baptist, to the holy Apostles Peter and Paul, to all the Saints, and to you, brethren, that I have sinned exceedingly in thought, word, and deed: through my fault, through my fault, through my most grievous fault. Therefore I beseech blessed Mary ever Virgin, blessed Michael the Archangel, blessed John the Baptist, the holy Apostles Peter and Paul, all the Saints, and you, brethren, to pray for me to the Lord our God.

Or . . .

I confess to the Cask, to King Bacchus and to all his cups taken up by us, that I, a drinker, have drunk exceedingly while standing, sitting, watching, waking, gambling, and inclining toward the cup, and in losing my clothes, through my drunkenness, through my drunkenness, though my most extreme drunkenness. Therefore I beseech you, solemn drinkers and diners, to pray devotedly for me.

In the parodies, liturgy is transformed to be consistent with excessive drinking and gambling. In the parodic penitential act (confession), the phrase “through my fault, through my fault, through my most grievous fault {mea culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa}” becomes “through my drunkenness, through my drunkenness, though my most extreme drunkenness {mea crapula, mea crapula, mea maxima crapula}.” Many other liturgical expressions are similarly transformed:

the most common exchange of the Mass Dominus vobiscum / Et cum spiritu tuo (The Lord by with you / And with your spirit) becomes Dolus vobiscum / Et cum gemitur tuo (Fraud be with you / And with your groan). The prompt to prayer Oremus (Let us pray) becomes Potemus (Let us drink) or Ploremus (Let us cry). Laus tibi Christe (Praise to you, Christ), a response pronounced after the Gospel, becomes the anti-peasant quip Fraus tibi, rustice (Fraud to you, peasant). The words of the preface Dignum et iustum est (It is fitting and right) become either Vinum et mustum est (There is wine and must) or Merum et mustum est (There is unmixed wine and must). Amen becomes stramen (straw); Alleluia becomes allecia (herring); and certain transitional words are subtly altered — ideo (thus) becomes rideo (I laugh). The titles of liturgical books are also changed, turning the Letter of Paul to the Hebraeos (Hebrews) into the letter to the Ebrios (drunkards). … The introduction to the Pater noster, Audemus dicere (We dare to say) becomes Audemus bibere (We dare to drink), and the first line is changed from Pater noster, qui es in caelis (Our Father, who is in Heaven) to Potus noster, qui est in cyphy (Our drink, which is in the cup). [3]

EDIT

https://www.purplemotes.net/2020/01/05/medieval-parodies-liturgy/



Arne

(3,609 posts)
29. Yesterday I spent some time searching for that Latin.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:28 AM
Jul 2024

As a young alter boy the church was just switching to English.
I couldn't remember the responses.
Thanx.

Siwsan

(27,631 posts)
15. I have zero interest in the Olympics but now I wish I had watched this opening ceremony!!!
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:38 AM
Jul 2024

All of my interest disappeared when they started allowing professionals to compete. Kind of went against what I thought was the heart of the Olympics.

But, that's just me. I certainly understand and respect other's interest.

Maybe I'll look around on YouTube to see what I can find.

LisaM

(29,301 posts)
18. It definitely evoked a PAINTING of the Last Supper.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:59 AM
Jul 2024

And it had a little Bacchus thrown in. I am Catholic and it didn't offend me in the least. I liked the intent of tolerance and inclusion.

But the painting of the Last Supper isn't the Last Supper itself. It's a highly symbolic interpretation. If there was a Last Supper, it likely looked very little like that.

eppur_se_muova

(39,543 posts)
22. Ever wonder why everyone is sitting on the same side of the table ?
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:04 AM
Jul 2024

It made a better painting. Nothing realistic there.

yorkster

(3,274 posts)
41. He was Painter to the Court of Christ.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 12:27 PM
Jul 2024

Last edited Sun Jul 28, 2024, 02:13 PM - Edit history (1)

A few years later, Francis 1 brought him to
Amboise where he lived out his life, creative to the end.
Leonardo did affirm that his time with Jesus and the Gang of Twelve had been
" a most interesting period in my life".


Mr.Bill

(24,906 posts)
40. This reminds me of an old joke.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 12:27 PM
Jul 2024

On the evening of the last supper, Christ and his 12 disciples went looking for a restaurant that could accomidate them. Without reservations, they had trouble finding a place that could. After a long search, they finally found an eatery that could, but the hostess told them "We can accomidate all 13 of you, but the table is on an aisle, so you will all have to sit on one side of it."

forgotmylogin

(7,910 posts)
45. Every theater person knows...
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 01:15 PM
Jul 2024

When you stage a large "dinner" at a table, you pretty much have to put all the participants on the upstage side facing the audience.

Similarity does not always imply intention.

If you've got a large group of people behind a table, it's going to evoke the Last Supper pretty much no matter what you do. Take a look at this picture from the musical Matilda. It's a birthday party but sure, out of context you could say it resembles the Last Supper.

https://criticalconfabulations.wordpress.com/2013/04/16/broadway-theatre-review-matilda-the-musical/

Every large thanksgiving dinner resembles the Last Supper. Every board room meeting at a long table resembles the Last Supper. The chest-bursting scene in ALIEN during a meal looks like the Last Supper.

lonely bird

(2,430 posts)
58. I liked Mel Brooks version in History of the World
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 03:24 PM
Jul 2024

And also the one from M.A.S.H movie.

wendyb-NC

(4,416 posts)
20. That is priceless
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:02 AM
Jul 2024

Thanks, for posting that. I didn't get to watch the opening ceremonies. I read that there were reports in the media, some "Christians" in the community at large, found the imagery offensive, because they felt it mocked religion. Well wouldn't you know. Great response from Lady Francis

Comfortably_Numb

(4,188 posts)
21. Xns, magats, and worst of all, magat "Xns" so quick to get butt hurt. Snowflake mofos always have to make it about them
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:02 AM
Jul 2024

chouchou

(2,194 posts)
24. Ha! Well, frankly..I'll just be upset and speak my mind and do my best to find ...
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:10 AM
Jul 2024

....some other societal misstep, so I can moan and gripe like a banshee....yes sir!

NoSheep

(8,301 posts)
25. my friend pointed out the hypocrites are CINOs...yes they are
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:16 AM
Jul 2024

Christians In Name Only

Kali

(56,337 posts)
26. then why the apologies?
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:16 AM
Jul 2024

why not explain? or not. either way, these whining morons who call other people snowflakes can just fuck off.

Iggo

(49,026 posts)
27. "The Last Supper" isn't the last supper, either.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:20 AM
Jul 2024

It’s a pop culture depiction. Are they offended by that, too?

Bernardo de La Paz

(57,295 posts)
31. "If you weren't so busy trying to end the Dept of Education, you might know this". Bingo. . . .nt
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:46 AM
Jul 2024

liberalla

(10,613 posts)
32. Thank you Lady Francis!
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:47 AM
Jul 2024


"If
some of you weren't so busy trying to end the Dept. of Education, you might know this."


ananda

(32,659 posts)
33. Whoa, that was awesome! Last part really hits home.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 11:55 AM
Jul 2024

"If some of you weren't so busy trying to end the
Dept of Education, you might know this."
"

joanbarnes

(2,018 posts)
34. This was served on a platter to a tRumpy Christian relative.........by someone else
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 12:02 PM
Jul 2024

... tRumper STILL argued it insulted Christianity!

dawg

(10,777 posts)
36. Dear Republicans,
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 12:14 PM
Jul 2024

Don't like the weird blue dude? Then just don't look at him.

It's that easy.

We don't own the Olympics.

UTUSN

(74,959 posts)
42. K&R. Mythvision Podcast (Derek LAMBERT) on YouTube provides tons of this info
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 12:28 PM
Jul 2024

Last edited Sun Jul 28, 2024, 02:30 PM - Edit history (1)

In the past few years I’ve been studying via The University of YouTube, a very large component of which has been modern scholarship of the emergence of Christianity, which turns on its head what we all grew up with. A main thread has been how both Testaments were written in a particularly Greek world, with the literary models of Homer, myths and legends being rewritten into the Bible. So the French put on their spectacular show incorporating educated, literary references including the one that uneducated wingnut fundamentalists (who are very UNchristian) think supposedly mocks the Last Supper. I had already seen a dozen or more videos about Dionysus being one of the several gods of some different cultures that Jesus was based on (death and resurrection), last suppers and bread/wine. So, no, today’s outraged “christians” are wrong again about THEIR being mocked. Now, the part with the beheaded Marie Antoinette might be justified as her representing symbolically the threat to democracy, am looking at Kathy GRIFFIN's posing with Drumpf's head.

So there’s a BBC clip with a panel (all Brits), excoriating over this “last supper” their ancient enemies, the French, one dude calling them “obnoxious, rude, stupid, started the Vietnam war, never funny” and more. Actually for a couple of centuries after 1066 the “Brits” were Normans and spoke French. And modern Brits put a distance between themselves and Americans, saying, “We are Europeans.”

My takeaway impressions were the erudite references of the whole spectacle, Celine’s pulling off the performance after all we’ve heard has been how ill she has been, and how the French merely stand with simple dignity for La Marsellaise with their hands at their sides and only put the hand to heart at the end while American civilians do hand-heart throughout the anthem.





Dark n Stormy Knight

(10,414 posts)
44. More precisely, imo, belligerent ignorance.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 01:15 PM
Jul 2024

Read that phrase somewhere to describe MAGAts and thought it was perfect!

poozwah

(345 posts)
46. so what?
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 01:18 PM
Jul 2024

so the christshuns are offended, who cares? they should be more offended by the blasphemy that is donald trump.

gulliver

(13,454 posts)
47. It does show you where MAGA lostie mindsets are
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 01:43 PM
Jul 2024

It kind of amazes me that we think their being "wrong" is the most important thing. Nope. It's their being on their last nerve. The being wrong is just them trying to rationalize voting for Trump and skipping any and all homework. And Trump loves this orgy of anger that he feeds with lies, stage hypnotism voice, and pseudo-religion. Pretty revolting.

BrianTheEVGuy

(697 posts)
48. Typical American conservatives
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 01:57 PM
Jul 2024

They center everything around themselves and their own culture and context. Because they're so ignorant and poorly educated, they're reactionary about everything they are ignorant about (which is most things). Because they're conservatives, they cannot function in life without having something to both hate and fear.

No explanation will suffice for them, because they're conservatives -- which means they're proudly ignorant. Being stupid and refusing to learn and grow is core to their identity, because if they did either of those things, they'd no longer be angry and hateful all the time.

SleeplessinSoCal

(10,214 posts)
55. Some Christians desperately need to get educated.
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 02:41 PM
Jul 2024

They're a danger to everyone including themselves.

tornado34jh

(1,495 posts)
56. France has always been secular and anti-clericalism (i.e. opposed to religious authority)
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 02:57 PM
Jul 2024

Yes, most are Roman Catholic, but I don't think I have heard them complaining about it. The ones complaining are probably not from France.

SpankMe

(3,539 posts)
57. Conspiracy theorist assholes
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 03:11 PM
Jul 2024

Leave it to RW'ers to interpret everything they see as a sleight against them. These paragons of self-reliance and critics of "snowflake-dom" always position themselves as victims.

Only terrorism is a more pathetic personal and cultural philosophy.

As for the alleged sexual themes in the opening ceremonies - these are the French, not the Saudis. French culture is notorious for erotic or sexual themes in everything. When I visited France in my early 20's, I noted that they ran softcore porn on broadcast television late at night.

Loosen the grip on your pearls, indeed.

DENVERPOPS

(13,003 posts)
64. For them, it pays to be ignorant
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 05:28 PM
Jul 2024

that way, they never have to think for themselves.........Really apparent these days, just look at Trump. Makes me wonder how he, and many other Republican Politicians ever graduated the third grade......

Hassler

(4,464 posts)
65. Don Jr is one of the outraged "Xtians"
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 06:03 PM
Jul 2024

The guy shacking up with whatever Kimberly Guilfoyle is these days.

Response to Dem4life1234 (Reply #67)

raising2moredems

(733 posts)
69. most who claim to be "christian"
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 10:40 PM
Jul 2024

are weak in their faith. No way could any of them put it all on the line for their professed "religion". Get a grip is all I can say. Their time could be spent helping those less fortunate but they have little appetite to do so.

B.See

(5,972 posts)
77. Dem said: "They just want to find something to bitch about France"
Mon Jul 29, 2024, 02:29 AM
Jul 2024

Exactly. MAGAts are pissed that France put down a fascist uprising. So understandably their opening ceremonies were designed to 1) honour their history and 2) celebrate DIVERSITY, TOLERANCE, AND INCLUSION.

Notions that many claim to believe in but maybe some don't. Certainly not Trump and his MAGA disciples, that's for sure. And diversity is what the Olympics are all ABOUT.

Re. the so-called offensive scenes? Hey, I'm Catholic and found nothing offensive about it. In fact, didn't particularly recall having even seen them. Tho maybe I'd glanced away for a second to look at some porn.

(jk. thems JOKES, y'all)

anniebelle

(914 posts)
78. Fake Christians
Mon Jul 29, 2024, 06:20 AM
Jul 2024

These faux Christians are always in an uproar over something. They don't seem to be outraged over this most un-Christian candidate, tRump.

ProfessorGAC

(73,761 posts)
80. Care To Elaborate?
Mon Jul 29, 2024, 06:28 PM
Jul 2024

Seems awfully condescending without further exposition.
Also, how is an opinion "gaslighting"?

Iggo

(49,026 posts)
81. Just because they're bad Xians doesn't mean they're fake.
Tue Jul 30, 2024, 12:51 PM
Jul 2024

To the rest of us, they’re all too real.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»It Was NOT The Last Suppe...