General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsTrump Trashes the U.S. as a 'STUPID Country' of 'SUCKERS' in Birthright Citizenship Rant
Trumpland
Trump Trashes the U.S. as a STUPID Country of SUCKERS in Birthright Citizenship Rant
LISTEN UP, SCOTUS
The president also offered the Supreme Court a very questionable history lesson about the 14th Amendment.
Janna Brancolini
Updated May 15 2025 11:53AM EDT
Published May 15 2025 11:23AM EDT
President Donald Trump ranted against the U.S. and its centuries-long tradition of birthright citizenship, saying the U.S. is a STUPID Country of SUCKERS, as the Supreme Court prepared to take up the issue Thursday.
snip//
The drug cartels love it! We are, for the sake of being politically correct, a STUPID Country, he added.
The issue hasnt got anything to do with political correctness, though, and everything to do with the Constitution. The 14th Amendments Citizenship Clause states: All persons born in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States.
more...
https://www.thedailybeast.com/trump-trashes-the-us-as-a-stupid-country-of-suckers-in-birthright-citizenship-rant/
Walleye
(43,710 posts)Nobody will even write a tweet to contradict him. Nation of cowards.
BadgerMom
(3,377 posts)Walleye
(43,710 posts)jls4561
(2,826 posts)They were allegedly carrying suitcases full of cash.
Hekate
(100,131 posts)UTUSN
(76,703 posts)greatauntoftriplets
(178,590 posts)Bernardo de La Paz
(60,320 posts)Bernardo de La Paz
(60,320 posts)Johonny
(25,291 posts)But if being born in America doesn't bring citizenship, isn't that a big turnoff to his whole let's repopulate America campaign?
zorbasd
(511 posts)he means re-populate with only white people.
Vogon_Glory
(10,171 posts)The sort of white people that some far right Xenophobic ideologues and theoreticians fantasize about would be too clever to vote for MAGA candidates .
As a straight white male of a certain age, I find these MAGA influencers and politicos to be extremely embarrassing.
ananda
(34,308 posts)If much of my extended family is anything to go by,
he's succeeding here in Texas.
ShazzieB
(22,148 posts)He wants to make this country a white supremacist paradise!

Lovie777
(21,578 posts)Well it begins at the top.
bdamomma
(69,139 posts)His idiocy is what he is doing to our country.
This country did elect his stupid ass twice, so he's kind of got a point.
C_U_L8R
(48,794 posts)Delmette2.0
(4,465 posts)bdamomma
(69,139 posts)he can STFU, move to Qatar, or Saudi Arabia or any dictatorship country and leave us the fuck alone to have some sanity.
ret5hd
(22,128 posts)what if your grandparents werent? Then your parents werent so you arent.
what about great grandparents? Then your grandparents werent, so your parents werent , so you arent.
okay
so great great grandparents. See where im going? The only citizens are native americans.
i may be able to live with that.
GoCubsGo
(34,636 posts)that those gifting it to him were trying to get rid of the heap for decades, is calling other people "stupid"? Holy shit. Talk about projection. I don't know who is more stupid, that drug-addled motherfucker, or the imbeciles who voted for him.
IIRC, one of his professors at Penn called him "the dumbest goddam student I ever had."
1WorldHope
(1,829 posts)America, love it, or leave it.
Me thinks he should leave Now!
Move to the middle east and see how much they like you when you don't have a country to offer them anymore.
allegorical oracle
(6,136 posts)states opting out.
Hypothetical given was NJ and PA. If, say, you were born in NJ, you would be born a citizen. If you were born in PA, you wouldn't. But if you traveled from PA to NJ (and it's a "porous" state, the attorney said), you would be a citizen while in NJ, but not a citizen when you returned to PA. The reverse would be the case if you were in NJ and traveled to PA.
Likewise, if you were born in a birthright citizenship state, you would be issued a SS upon birth. Not so in PA. And if a family moved from PA to NJ (the attorney said 6,000 such moves occur each year), NJ would have to spend money and time establishing citizenship for "new families" that arrived.
This concept sounds like a nightmare akin to the abortion issue -- where it's legal in some states and not others. The logical result is people would flock to birthright citizenship states. Then what? A law would be passed that requires everyone to remain in the state where they were born for their lifetime?
et tu
(2,387 posts)america first!!!!
CloudWatcher
(2,127 posts)I can agree with him on this. For proof we just have to look at the last election and note the number of people that voted for him, or didn't bother to vote. Stupid Country of Suckers doesn't begin to describe my disgust with the lazy fools and maggots.
Ofc the current court case should never have made it this far. The 14th Amendment is not hard to understand. The first part of the 14th Amendment:
Perhaps they'd like to get rid of the "due process" part as well, since that appears to be effectively being ignored by this administration.
Oh! And all of the rest of it too, there's Section 3 that should have disqualified Trump from holding office:
Anyone with a working neuron would know that Trump has at least "given aid or comfort" to the insurrectionists of January 6. And Congress did not by 2/3 vote remove the ban against him running for high office.
I wonder if they want the whole 14th removed as it was passed under duress?
From the Senate page on the 14th: Congress required former Confederate states to ratify the Fourteenth Amendment as a condition of regaining federal representation.
So surely this amendment in its entitreity is null and void?
But the Supreme Court has no right to "overturn" the 14th, so I suggest we amend the constitution to remove Birthright Citizenship retroactively to 1776. A nation run only by Native Americans could be interesting.
In the meantime, how about we require people swearing to uphold the Constitution to affirm that they have actually read the thing? Trump wasn't lying when he said "I don't know" if he had to uphold the Constitution. I suspect he's never read any of it.
Wiz Imp
(8,748 posts)chowder66
(11,761 posts)It's abused by people from other countries. They come here very pregnant and have their child who gets citizenship, then they typically go back home.
Our building complex in L.A. had two waves of Russian women who did this. There are minders that charge a big fee and help them with the process, find lodging, hospitals, etc.
Wiz Imp
(8,748 posts)According to the Niskanen Center, the likely number is only about 2000 per year, hardly an existential crisis.
https://www.niskanencenter.org/the-birth-tourism-bogeyman/
chowder66
(11,761 posts)And make money off of it.
lostnfound
(17,383 posts)Mr.Bee
(1,614 posts)Trump, the recipient of long tradition of birthright citizenship.
Botany
(76,254 posts)The 39 delegates who signed the Constitution on September 17, 1787, and the states they represented were as follows:
Washington, George, Virginia
Franklin, Benjamin, Pennsylvania
Madison, James, Virginia Hamilton, Alexander, New York
Morris, Gouverneur, Pennsylvania
Morris, Robert, Pennsylvania
Wilson, James, Pennsylvania
Pinckney, Chas. Cotesworth, South Carolina
Pinckney, Chas, South Carolina
Rutledge, John, South Carolina
Butler, Pierce, South Carolina
Sherman, Roger, Connecticut
Johnson, William Samuel, Connecticut
McHenry, James, Maryland
Read, George, Delaware
Bassett, Richard, Delaware
Spaight, Richard Dobbs, North Carolina
Blount, William, North Carolina
Williamson, Hugh, North Carolina
Jenifer, Daniel of St. Thomas, Maryland
King, Rufus, Massachusetts
Gorham, Nathaniel, Massachusetts
Dayton, Jonathan, New Jersey
Carroll, Daniel, Maryland
Few, William, Georgia
Baldwin, Abraham, Georgia
Langdon, John, New Hampshire
Gilman, Nicholas, New Hampshire
Livingston, William, New Jersey
Paterson, William, New Jersey
Mifflin, Thomas, Pennsylvania
Clymer, George, Pennsylvania
FitzSimons, Thomas, Pennsylvania
Ingersoll, Jared, Pennsylvania
Bedford, Gunning, Jr., Delaware
Brearley, David, New Jersey
Dickinson, John, Delaware
Blair, John, Virginia
Broom, Jacob, Delaware
******
If we really had a legitimate free press Krasnov would have been asked about
our founding fathers and which one were suckers?
Good God in Butter this is madness.
BoRaGard
(7,591 posts)So now it's everyone.
Screw you Krasnov, and your billionaire bro republicon parasites.
Balatro
(51 posts)So drug cartels love coming here,
1. having babies then
2. ?????
3. Profit?
xuplate
(156 posts)There were enough suckers in this country to get him reelected.
Vinca
(53,220 posts)mgardener
(2,281 posts)How much money he made from birth tourism especially from Russia.
https://www.pbssocal.org/shows/to-the-contrary/clip/ttc-extra-russian-birth-tourism-trump-properties-qj0wgl
https://theweek.com/speedreads/748344/russian-birth-tourists-are-flocking-miami-trump-condos-give-birth-american-citizens
https://www.standard.co.uk/lifestyle/london-life/russians-flock-to-give-birth-at-trump-s-properties-in-the-us-so-their-kids-can-have-dualcitizenship-a3628971.html
Iamscrewed
(486 posts)Deport his kids.
Henry203
(832 posts)and were the people treated like the "brown people" today. They are the only people who had a law passed to keep them out. My Grandfather was a birthright citizen who was deported. It took him 15 years to get back and the 1898 ruling for Wong is probably the only reason he got back.
Seventeen of my eighteen cousinds received their 4 year degrees. The only one who didn't finished 3 years. She was so a smart she skipped a grade. Compare that to the losers on the typical republican side.
My other grandfateher was ILLEGAL and his wife( my grandmother ) was arrested for being with him in 1910.
TODAY'S republicans are racist assholes.
Wonder Why
(6,513 posts)stupid, what would you call a country they live in?
I live in a stupid MAGAt state (NC) and a stupid country. Doesn't mean all of us are, but the country qualifies.
ShazzieB
(22,148 posts)I was a little disappointed to find that the article was about a Truth Social post. I clicked on it hoping to see some juicy video footage.
Also, who wants to bet Stephen Miller wrote this for him? Not just because of the correct grammar, punctuation, and spelling, and the lack of typos, but because Schlump could never write something this long that stays on track to the end and contains facts like the year the Civil War ended. He couldn't even read something this long much less write it!
Before I go, here's an archive link that doesn't require registration to read it:
https://archive.ph/2025.05.15-154857/https://www.thedailybeast.com/trump-trashes-the-us-as-a-stupid-country-of-suckers-in-birthright-citizenship-rant/
MLWR
(746 posts)you can always leave. Most of us won't try to keep you here against your will.
UpInArms
(53,960 posts)this POS makes me vomit
Jit423
(1,568 posts)Just asking.
Wiz Imp
(8,748 posts)However since they all still had one parent who was a US citizen at the time of their birth, they would still be citizens.