General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsProgressive YouTubers HATE This One Simple Trick! (Shocking Media Secrets Revealed!) 😱🔥
Is THIS the Shocking Reason Progressive YouTube is Officially DEAD?! (What They Aren't Telling You! 👇IT'S OVER!! Why I Had to UNFOLLOW MeidasTouch and Really American IMMEDIATELY!! 🛑👀
Every day, I continue to lose what little respect (and hope) that remained for progressive Youtube channels. Ive reached my breaking point with "progressive" independent YouTube news. I recall that many people, like myself, turned to channels like Really American, MeidasTouch, and their affiliates (and many others) because we were tired of corporate MSM treating politics like a sport and prioritizing ad revenue over substance.
Independent creators promised to be different. Instead, they have become the very thing they used to criticize. They have built their own commercialized outrage farms, enslaved to the dictates of the YouTube algorithm rather than the pursuit of objective truth.
Just scroll through these channels on any given day, the manipulation is glaringly obvious:
--- Algorithmic Churn: Sensationalized, AI-generated thumbnail photos... bright yellow arrows pointing at nothing.
--- "Betteridge" Headlines: Provocative question headlines (the objective answer is always a resounding "no.'')
--- Fluff and Padding: Taking a concise 2-minute press release or court filing and s-t-r-e-t-c-h-i-n-g it into a repetitive, padded 10-minute video purely to qualify for a mid-roll advertisement placement.
This is poison!! When progressive media resorts to exaggeration, hyperbole, and manufactured urgency for the sake of clicks, it fundamentally insults the intelligence of the progressive base. It dumbs-us-down. It makes us look as gullible and stupid and as easily manipulated as the MAGA cult.
By constantly dialing up the outrage baiting to ELEVEN over every minor development, these channels create a boy-who-cried-wolf scenario. It erodes our media literacy, and it mimics the worst bad-faith echo chambers of the right, and ultimately breeds deep cynicism and distrust.
So I choose to vote against this SLOP by scrolling away and not giving them the "click" or the "like" or the subscription. We cannot expect these platforms to get better if we continue to feed the beast and take the bait.
Not that these channels would have noticed or cared, but I've now unsubscribed from them all. This won't change their tactics, but I feel better knowing that I don't support it. (Though YouTube still keeps suggesting that crap to me, and I'll keep clicking "not interested" and "don't recommend channel" in response. In time, I hope, my YT feed will become more interesting and less insulting.)
Are any other DUers feeling this profound burnout with progressive YouTube? How are you curating your media diet to stay informed without losing your mind?
BY THE WAY... BE SURE TO LEAVE ME A LIKE... OR SUBSCRIBE... AND POST YOUR COMMENTS BELOW! AND DON'T FORGET ABOUT MY PATREON PAGE WHERE YOU CAN GET EXCLUSIVE SLOP, RANTING AND NAVEL-GAZING!
FalloutShelter
(14,789 posts)Cannot agree more.
I never want to hear the work BOMBSHELL ever again.
Unless it is this
FakeNoose
(43,358 posts)Try it, it works. I've trashed so many similar words and none of that shows up on my feed.
Also I think I've trashed the entire YouTubers forum, but I still see a few of them on my front page.
Baitball Blogger
(53,001 posts)paleotn
(23,261 posts)For those of us who grew up with Walter anyway. A time when journalism was fully professionalized. I fear it's reverted back to what it was in the 19th century. This isn't anything new. Back then, anyone who could get their hands on a press could spew total BS and many did. Their reach was far more limited in most cases than today, but it was a torrent of bullshit nonetheless.
ornotna
(11,636 posts)More clickbait complaining about clickbait.
QueerDuck
(2,490 posts)
Ms. Toad
(38,979 posts)Not a fan of hyperbole, half-truths, etc.
DinahMoeHum
(23,801 posts)I've also steered clear of Meidas Touch recently because of this.
Bengus81
(10,724 posts)When in reality it was a large piece of I guess metal that fell. Why use the bullshit tag line when the TRUTH was better?
There were girls on that stage practicing for a show. Some of them could have been injured badly or killed--that's the STORY,not some bullshit nonsense that the stage collapsed.
IMO it's gone from what was good to see how much jack you can rake in so keep the "content" coming at a rate of seemingly one per hour. With loads of video from the one that was posted two hours ago.
TVguyCards
(144 posts)doing this but basically a whole lot of channels from all walks of life outside of politics.
The reason?
You have less than 2 seconds to get the attention of a viewer. This goes back to the old magazine era when places like grocery stores had multiple aisles filled with magazines (who else remembers that? 😀 ) and that still applies today on sites like YouTube. It's done intentionally. And can you blame them?
It's important that we remember many of these channels are basically a 1 or 2 man show. It's their sole source of income so advertising dollars is how they make their money. Naturally the more viewers you get the more money you make so ya, you want something which immediately engages the viewer so they find it interesting and therefor will click to watch it.
The problem I have is when the thumbnail is misinformation and very misleading. That though is of course a different issue entirely but it does warrant it to be brought up and put into context. They're doing what they need to do in order to make a living so the scenario is "Don't hate the player, hate the game!"
FYI - I definitely don't consider MeidasTouch "Progressive" by any means of the word. I see them as a standard Liberal channel. Now I know you're going to ask me "Well what do you consider progressive to be then?" So I thought I'd share a few channels with you of some of my favorite leftist channels. These include both progressive and the Socialist left.
And maybe some others will fine these channels good and interesting too. YMMV 👍
The Majority Report
Matt Binder who also hosts the Leftist Mafia with several hosts. It's VERY good!
The Humanist Report
Punch Up Pod
The Vanguard
Katie Halper
U.S. Democratic Socialists
Secular Talk
The Rational National
The Serf Times
Hasan
Drop Site News
dweller
(29,067 posts)These channels in a stand alone post to make them accessible as a bookmark
Thanks
✌🏻
3825-87867
(2,067 posts)Simply copy each and insert in your url section and enter.
Also, to save a link, right click the underlined and blue text, select "copy link" then save it to note pad or whatever to access later.
These all should work
https://www.youtube.com/@TheMajorityReport
https://www.youtube.com/@MattBinder
https://www.youtube.com/@TheHumanistReport
https://www.youtube.com/@punchuppod
https://www.youtube.com/@TheVanguardPod
https://www.youtube.com/@TheKatieHalperShow
https://www.youtube.com/@USDemSocialists
https://www.youtube.com/@SecularTalk
https://www.youtube.com/@therationalnational
https://www.youtube.com/@TheSerfTimes
https://www.youtube.com/@HasanAbi
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBMrOkjg3AbvLS5g1MhtlRQ
Rastapopoulos
(756 posts)Whenever I see the headline "Trump Collapses" or "Trump Melts Down" I click, hoping that this is finally "it." It never is of course and I sit thru 15 minutes of built-up, pleas for clicks, and irrelevancies. If I knew how, I would block it from my suggested videos. It would certainly save me a lot of time and frustration. I will give some of these a try, but I usually watch on my Roku TV.
LeftInTX
(35,223 posts)We will all know about it and it won't say collapse or melt down or devastated.
A_Woman_from_MI
(206 posts)I'd add the I've had it podcast https://www.youtube.com/@ivehaditpodcast
masmdu
(2,656 posts)More perfect union
https://youtube.com/@moreperfectunion?si=us8v2t0GSN9eQG9J
Cirsium
(4,323 posts)Last edited Sat Jul 11, 2026, 12:19 PM - Edit history (1)
Well said! We have a bunch of grifters - supposedly "on our side" - who are cashing in on this national tragedy. It is disgusting.
WhiskeyGrinder
(27,490 posts)Raftergirl
(2,030 posts)they can make by getting subscribers and the numbers of views. Thats how they make money. Which, of course is their sole goal.
Its all content creators on YouTube, not just progressive content creators.
If you want real news, read a newspaper, or mags like The Atlantic or The New Yorker, etc., which have real serious journalist writing for them.
The amount of posts with crap from YouTube channels just on this site is disturbing, imo.
And stop using the term main stream media, which the right used to tar and feather journalism, and which the left has now happily jumped on that bandwagon, too.
Thats how they got so many people to watch Fox News when they brandished everything else, at the time, Main Street Media. Now Fox is considered that so they turned to the news outlets that are even worse propagandist.
The stupid on both sides is scary and reflects, what I consider, mass gullibility by a majority of the people who have the attention span of gnats.
QueerDuck
(2,490 posts)🍷🍷
IrishAfricanAmerican
(4,557 posts)PatSeg
(54,255 posts)I never was a huge follower of these channels, but occasionally I watched them. Initially, I disliked how they took a five minute story and stretched it to 20 or more, often interrupting a video clip to throw in their commentary (which I did not need or want).
But now they're employing all these tabloid-like devices that you mentioned. The most annoying for me is that stupid yellow arrow. Reminds me of a Batman comic book.
In the end, I prefer to read information over watching a video that often runs far too long. If I watch YouTube it is maybe for interviews of people I'm interested in or documentaries, rarely politics.
FakeNoose
(43,358 posts)If I do watch one of those, I usually say "get to the f***ing point" within 2 minutes.
PatSeg
(54,255 posts)"Get to the f***ing point" many times. If I'm reading an article, I can skim redundant parts and read at my own pace. I don't want to spend 20-30 minutes listening to someone else explain it in their own drawn out version.
dlk
(13,520 posts)Your concern is explained, as well as what can be done.
Shipwack
(3,144 posts)Belle of the Ranch
Heather Cox Richardson
et al
Amaryllis
(11,603 posts)BlueKota
(5,625 posts)TBF
(37,817 posts)is that what you were going for here?
I'm not a big you tube user, I get most of my subscriptions via Substack and would rather read Ben Meiselas (Meidas) than watch the shows. But you do understand these folks are supporting, advocating, and voting for dems - correct?
Do you also understand they are not supported by PAC's and probably need that ad revenue to keep their shows going?
My suggestion would be to not split the party as that guarantees a certain loss in the midterms. Let's find ways democrats can welcome progressives (understanding that it goes both ways) and actually work together.
I agree with the poster above - there are good shows like Aaron Parnas that simply reports the news (without yellow arrows if that's your primary concern).
B.See
(9,108 posts)limit our left leaning sources of information and get all finicky about 'click bait' wording while MAGAS consume outright fabricated Fux 'news' propaganda on a 24/7 basis.
Sounds like one helluva plan.
Btw, I'm not referring to YouTube content because I don't watch any of it. Haven't the patience.
But I have had to fend off similar criticism of news items from some left leaning news sources.
Cheezoholic
(4,221 posts)Content is the most important thing. The Tennessee Firecracker Stand headlines irritate the hell out of me but once again its content I'm interested in. The Algorithm needs you to bite all the time to work. I go to their website when it comes to MTN.
mn9driver
(4,872 posts)The real world is scary enough. That stuff is insulting clickbait.
ToxMarz
(3,239 posts)but their message is generally aligned with progressive messaging which I can't fault them for. They do have a lot of followers/subscribers so someone is getting the message and maybe it's someone who isn't being reached any other way, so I'm fine with that too. I don't fault them because they need to monetize their channels because how else are they going to be able devot the time and resources to produce it. Again, I don't care for the way they do it, so I generally don't watch it. That's just my solution, but I don't feel the need to persuade others not to if they enjoy it. Their message I find generally agreeable
WestMichRad
(3,577 posts)
or like ANYTHING. Ill look for the content providers that I want, such as (but not only)
Glenn Kirschner
Harry Litman
Marc Elias / Democracy Docket
Heather Cox Richardson
Institute for Justice
I still get a lot of crap recommendations from YouTube, including lots that look like AI, but I think I get less crap than I might if I were to subscribe to channels or like posts. And if I miss important stuff, meh. Ill catch up later.
QueerDuck
(2,490 posts)...that this has ultimately become. --- You've got the right attitude... you might "miss out" on the one time that a clickbait farm has something worthwhile, but if it's genuinely worthwhile and newsworthy, then someone else will be talking about it too. FOMO is something that clutters up one's feed too.
WestMichRad
(3,577 posts)Im not very tech savvy. (Had to look up what FOMO means.
)
Bev54
(13,575 posts)They are definitely prone to hyperbole and long winded stories with a lot of personal opinions. Not what I want, I am looking for facts and perhaps some interpretation. I notice their videos are getting longer and longer. If I do click on it will be for the first 3 minutes. I prefer to watch Aaron Parnas, Bryan Tyler Cohen, Large Man Abroad and the Damage report. Concise reporting on one subject at a time, Oh and Democracy watch as well. Being Canadian, my favourites are House of El (European) she does an AI one as well to keep up on that front. We have a few really good Canadian youtubers that are great as well.
Sympthsical
(11,369 posts)Just took a gander out of curiosity
Jesus Christ.
I feel sorry for the audience that is rotting their brain like that.
Now, let us all retreat to the bastion of objectivity and good sense . . . BlueSky.
WestMichRad
(3,577 posts)Some of them are AI imposter crap?
Bengus81
(10,724 posts)I've seen him on there days looking like absolute shit,like he hasn't slept or showered in days. I liked his channel a couple of years ago but it's just ridiculous today.
Sympthsical
(11,369 posts)But AI thumbnails are pretty standard on YouTube nowadays.
He's making bank, and I guarantee he's probably got a production staff of video editors, researchers, and script writers at this point.
Perhaps he aspires to be the Simon Whistler of Left politics. (Who also posts way too many videos and also has a production staff)
Keepthesoulalive
(2,509 posts)They tell the other side of the story and thoughtful well researched content. Heather Cox Richardson, Belle of the ranch, Tizzy, Danesh, Danainspired and a few others. Sensational ranting gets clicks and clicks mean money.
QueerDuck
(2,490 posts)... but he can be a little long-winded sometimes. I like his sensible take on a lot of things that he talks about.
Keepthesoulalive
(2,509 posts)Godless Gardener, The Enemy From Within hes a long haul trucker who speaks from the lower middle income spectrum and tells you what is happening in the country in terms of shipping.
Behind the Aegis
(56,359 posts)It isn't news as much as their opinions on the news. It gets tedious. I only watch a few sporadically and usually end up fast-forwarding thru "opinions". I watch some of the legal ones, especially when I am trying to understand what is happening in the law or SC. Like you said, many just say the same thing over and over. Rachel Maddow is horrible about this; her books, however, are fucking TOP NOTCH! Read them all!
So, I usually stick to pet videos (The Dodo is my fave) , gardening, lots of computer shit because my husband is IT, language programs, and cooking vids.
QueerDuck
(2,490 posts)IcyPeas
(26,055 posts)When he's gone so will most of these channels be gone.
They're raking in the $ while they can.
They're using us. Rage bait works on both sides.
Don't buy it.
Add Mary Trump to the list too. I'm tired of all the panels of experts on the tv every day too. Have these expert pundits actually helped? Mark Elias is one who is actually doing something.
This:
BY THE WAY... BE SURE TO LEAVE ME A LIKE... OR SUBSCRIBE... AND POST YOUR COMMENTS BELOW! AND DON'T FORGET ABOUT MY PATREON PAGE WHERE YOU CAN GET EXCLUSIVE SLOP, RANTING AND NAVEL-GAZING!
GoodRaisin
(11,229 posts)Like everything else you have to take it with a grain of salt. I never subscribe to anything, and I frequently use the slider through videos that are full of time wasting BS.
joanbarnes
(2,158 posts)Wednesdays
(23,613 posts)And for a short while I used AI for titles and descriptions. Those videos did no better, and in most cases did worse, than the ones with titles and descriptions I created myself.
Same thing with AI-generated thumbnails...the suggestions AI pose for my videos look ridiculous compared to the ones I make myself.
So, no AI-generated content from me.
Trueblue Texan
(4,753 posts)No longer sub or watch Midas, Parkrose Permaculture, Jack Coachierella, Your Dailly policy fix, among others, for the same reason. Gimme some news and stop wasting my damn time!
QueerDuck
(2,490 posts)... I was hopeful at first but it did not take long for disappointment to set in.
canetoad
(21,305 posts)If you just want to check something out, do it in a private tab and ignore the whining from YouTube. Their algorithm seems to be to bombard you with stuff you've already watched.
NeoTrajan
(107 posts)Progressives = BAD!
I despise everything you mentioned about those channels, but I find it hard to believe that Progressives, specifically, are the sole party in that mess, or that ALL Progressives participate in it because they are Progressive
Should I be concerned that I'LL suddenly start a YouTube channel so I can do all those awful things?
Ew .... I'll really hate my future AI slop channel ... I'll block myself if that happens
Nevertheless, I'll remain a dedicated Progressive, even without a greedy youtube AI slop channel
QueerDuck
(2,490 posts)I wish I could monetize my posts on DU!
BlueKota
(5,625 posts)I hate the headlines like "Trump's Terrified of Leaked Information, Finally Faces Justice, Is On His Last Legs, yet none of these ever pan out in reality.
I really want to scream at them, to shut their mouths. It's very rude to spread false hope.
mcar
(46,736 posts)They are pathetic.
Initech
(109,796 posts)It's even more annoying when they put a like and subscribe comment at the end!