Spain proposes 100% tax on homes bought by non-EU residents
Source: Guardian
Spain has announced plans to impose a tax of up to 100% on real estate bought by non-residents from countries outside the EU, such as the UK, in an aim to tackle the countrys housing crisis.
The measure was one of a dozen unveiled Monday by the countrys prime minister, Pedro Sánchez, as the government seeks to quell mounting anger over housing costs that have soared far beyond the reach of many in Spain.
-snip-
Sánchez described the tax of up to 100% as unprecedented in Spanish history. Just to give an idea, in 2023 alone non-European Union residents bought around 27,000 houses and flats in Spain. And they didnt do it to live in them, they didnt do it for their families to have a place to live, they did it to speculate, to make money from them, which we in the context of shortage that we are in obviously cannot allow.
-snip-
The governments slate of measures also took aim at tourist flats, which have long been blamed for shrinking the rental supply and leaving locals priced out of the market.
-snip-
Read more: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/jan/13/spain-proposes-100-tax-on-homes-bought-by-non-eu-residents
LisaM
(28,837 posts)It's a problem in every tourist town. But people like them and don't seem to care how they cut into housing stock or drive up rents.
You can bet if Barcelona handed out 10,000 actual licenses for short term rentals, the actual number was at least three to four times higher.
I am sorry maybe people who own homes, have big savings or have great credit can say that, but at our arbnb we get many families that have had evictions and can't find apartments easily or they can't afford 1st, last and security in south florida. I have also used these short term rentals for a year to wait to save for 3000,00 back in 2014, now its at least 5 grand. Lots of us have this problem. Mayhap arbnb etc needs to be eliminated, not all weekly places. They were around before arbnb and vrbo. A law would make it all go away.
KT2000
(21,031 posts)I live in a neighborhood that was established in 1964. It is a well-maintained neighborhood with a mix of homeowners and long-term renters. We are rural and near the water. The street on the water has motels. We are set back and have enjoyed this neighborhood which includes things such as a yearly neighborhood garage sale, yearly picnic in someone's yard, and the knowledge that in an emergency there are neighbors who will help. When 911 is called and they take a person to the hospital, we know there are people who will lock up the house and take care of the pets.
Short-term rentals destroy all of that. They break apart the very building blocks of society so individuals and investment firms can make money off of the house. They also drive up the cost of housing, creating a shortage.
My neighbor put her home on airbnb for a month. The character of the area changes when there is a steady stream of strangers next door instead of neighbors you know. They are used for parties, vetting is a joke, and management of any nuisance is left to the neighbors and the local sheriff office which is short on staff.
Short-term rentals exploit the efforts of those who make the neighborhood a nice place to live and are left with the prospect of living next door to a motel.
So far the concept of making money has won in the courts over the intangible of living in a safe neighborhood when it comes to regulating. The investment firms have the money to prevail.
We all know its the big business middleman like arbnb that have super charged it. Our place is very well policed by me, because we have residential neighbors. No parties, no loud noises after 10, but i cut it off at 9pm.
KT2000
(21,031 posts)who among those neighbors moved into their homes because they wanted to live next door to a motel? These things destroy neighborhoods and the conviviality and safety. It is not just big business; it is people who read financial newsletters and see a way to make money. They do not even live locally because in this area, they are not appreciated. They do not buy next to their own homes but go to well-maintained older neighborhoods that have not caught up to the exploitation of it and protected themselves.
This is why I just lurked on here since 2008
People like you!
I am done!
KT2000
(21,031 posts)that is different than yours. I would hope you would consider the opinions of those neighbors because living next to a motel is very much different than having neighbors. Sorry if that upsets you but we should consider how our actions affect others - even if it means making money.
paleotn
(19,729 posts)paleotn
(19,729 posts)If they're causing a serious problem, regulate them out of existence. Tell people to go find something else to like that's not so destructive.
travelingthrulife
(1,151 posts)The speculators really jacked up the cost of housing with their house flipping mania.
SheltieLover
(60,831 posts)JMO.
Dumpy
(57 posts)Force all vacations out of neighborhoods and back to commercial propteries.
snot
(10,910 posts)According to this 2018 article, the top ten biggest property owners in New York City include (among others) Vornado Realty Trust, SL Green Realty, Tishman Speyer Co., Blackstone Group, Related Companies, Brookfield Property Partners, and RXR Realty (see https://ny.curbed.com/2018/9/14/17860172/new-york-10-biggest-property-owners ).
Sociologist Saskia Sassen has done some brilliant work in this area; see, e.g., https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2015/nov/24/who-owns-our-cities-and-why-this-urban-takeover-should-concern-us-all :
....Since their beginnings, whether 3,000 years old or 100, cities have kept reinventing themselves, which means there are always winners and losers. Urban histories are replete with accounts of those who were once poor and quasi-outsiders, or modest middle classes, that gained ground because cities have long accommodated extraordinary variety.
But todays large-scale corporate buying of urban space in its diverse instantiations introduces a de-urbanising dynamic. It is not adding to mixity and diversity. Instead it implants a whole new formation in our cities in the shape of a tedious multiplication of high-rise luxury buildings.
This next article begins by studying changes in ownership in New York City's East Village over a twelve-year period and goes on to mention,
Since 2000, the number of Manhattan apartments occupied by absentee owners and renters swelled by more than 70 percent, to nearly 34,000, from 19,000,...
and
The article also mentions the process of layering: creating mazes of bank accounts and offshore companies to move and hide money in which if they are laid down skillfully, its often impossible for authorities to detect flows of illicit cash. Towers of Secrecy also went through how hard it was to investigate and find out who were the actual people behind the properties. LLCs, even if not created for those specific purposes, becomes a tool for some people to hide their secrets beyond just to remain private. They remain out of sight so their activities do so as well.
More at https://disquemechudo.github.io/who-owns-nyc/data-project-final.html .
Anyway, yay for Spain!
snot
(10,910 posts)about the possibility of individual municipalities outlawing or imposing heightened taxes on property and/or business ownership by non-residents (but I have no idea whether this would, e.g., pass constitutional muster).
LisaM
(28,837 posts)I don't think Airbnb is the only problem but in small tourist areas it's a huge one. There is enough housing stock. It's just not being allocated fairly.
James48
(4,632 posts)If there is more demand than supply, build some.
Much of Europe has vacant buildings. Italy, Sicily, Corsica, Crete all have buildings available for low cost. Yes, they need work, but for a hundred grand or less you can still make a nice home.
LisaM
(28,837 posts)Almost everything is small,. expensive apartments, mostly for one person. This is not fulfilling any long term need, middle class is pretty priced out, and the infrastructure is not keeping up with density (which is pretty intolerable if you have to live in it). Yet there are whole houses available all over town as Airbnbs, whole apartment buildings are Airbnbs, and a friend had to move out of her condo because it was full of tourists. This industry needs some serious regulation and limits.