What flavor or kind of ice cream is your favorite? Mine is Butter Pecan

[debm55]

[OLDMDDEM]

1. Pralines and Cream

[debm55]

2. Thank you very much OLDMDDEM. Enjoy.

[OLDMDDEM]

6. I will and have.

[brush]

90. Rum raisin.

[pansypoo53219]

63. butter brickel. butter pecan + praline. tho our local frozen custard place has cherry almaretto. choc covered cherries

in pink almond custard. + chocolate malt. light choc w/ crushed whoppers.

[RoadRunner]

3. Cookies & cream

Yummy.

[debm55]

5. Thank you so much RoadRunner. Enjoy your Cookies and Cream.

[Eugene]

4. fudge ripple

[debm55]

7. Yummy, Thank you Eugene and enjoy your fudge ripple

[SheltieLover]

8. Tillamook's Mudslide

Omg it's good, but very high fat content, sadly.

[debm55]

10. Thank you very much SheltieLover. When you can, enjoy.

[ArnoldLayne]

9. Chocolate Moose Tracks

[debm55]

12. Thank you very much, ArnoldLayne and enjoy.

[Squeaky41]

17. Ice Scream Favorites

1. French Vanilla

2. Chocolate Moose Tracks

3. Cherries Garcia

[debm55]

22. Wow! thank you very much Squeaky41. Enjoy them all

[doc03]

11. Wow that is a difficult question there are so many. Lets go with Praline Pecan

[debm55]

13. Yummy. Thank you very much doc03, Enjoy.

[LoisB]

14. #1 - Chocolate #2 - Butter Pecan

[debm55]

15. YES!!!! Thank you so much LoisB, Enjoy

[justaprogressive]

16. Peach!

Breyer's makes it but only when it was a great peach harvest in Georgia the previous season

....haven't seen it anywhere this year, even tho' it was a reportedly a great harvest last year???



However my wife (bless her!) found that Turkey Hill has a new Peach ice cream and bought some.

I can personally attest it is gloriously delicious! Maybe a limited release...look for it!

[debm55]

21. Wow. That sounds great. justaprogressive. Enjoy them both.

[electric_blue68]

73. You'll like this... When Ben & Jerry introduced themselves to NYC decades back, they held a Festival in Central Park...

To get Free Ice Cream you had to write a quick postcard for any of 3 choices of causes. 1 card, one scoop, 2, for 2, etc.

Chocolate for me, but they also had ?sweet ice cream with fresh peach slices! Which I'd never heard of. Oh, yum!
It takes something really serious to lure me away from chocolate! 😄

[highplainsdem]

18. Double Fudge Moose Tracks

https://kemps.com/freezer-products/double-fudge-moose-tracks-ice-cream/

[debm55]

25. Thank you very much, highplainsdem and enjoy.

[electric_blue68]

74. That looks like fun!

[EYESORE 9001]

19. Can't pick a favorite

but the last ice cream I had was a raspberry sorbet, which was awesome, and I guess that makes it my favorite until the next time I have something memorable.

[debm55]

24. Thank you very much, EYESORE 9001

[CanonRay]

20. Butter Pecan also

[debm55]

23. Thank you, CanonRay. Enjoy it.

[Walleye]

26. That just brought back an image of my mom, butter pecan was her favorite

Thank you. Memorial Day can be tough for some people. We used to always have fresh strawberries out of the garden with briars ice cream with vanilla beans.

[debm55]

47. I am so happy to bring back the good memories of your mom.Walleye

[Ocelot II]

27. All of it.

[debm55]

48. HAHAHHAHAHAH. Thank you Ocelot II. Enjoy

[MiHale]

28. Vanilla Honey Lavender...

Desert of the gods.

[debm55]

49. Oh my, that sounds wonderful, MiHale. Where do buy it? I would really like to try.

[MiHale]

71. It's a MooVille product...

At their ice cream and dairy stores in Michigan. My niece’s horse farm is down there, when we visit her downstate it’s always a stop.
https://www.moo-ville.com/Products#allflavors

https://www.moo-ville.com/

[electric_blue68]

75. That IS an impressive collection!

Just take my money.... hee, hee, hee

Lots of great choices!

[FM123]

29. Rocky Road!

Not just my favorite ice cream, but the story of my life lol.

[debm55]

50. Oh you, Enjoy you Rocky Road ice cream. FM123.

[OldBaldy1701E]

66. Same. On both accounts. (n/t)

[CrispyQ]

30. Private Selection Chocolate Ganache.

Deep chocolate velvet & not too sweet.

It reminds me of Dryers Dutch chocolate from many years ago. In the summer I'd keep a small bottle of peppermint schnapps in the freezer & pour a shot over my ice cream for an icy-cold, chocolaty-mint experience!

[debm55]

54. CrispyQ, That sounds terrific. Thank you for sharing your wonderful experience.

[underpants]

31. Oyster

I’d always understood that that was the first flavor of ice cream served in the White House but that may not be true.

[debm55]

51. HAHAHHHAAHHA. Are you pulling my leg underpants.

[Srkdqltr]

32. Chocolate chocolate and chocolate

[HappyH]

33. Vanilla

2 scoops with a handful of raspberries thrown in there. Won’t be much longer now, the raspberries are covered with blooms and the bees are busy!

[debm55]

52. Thank you very much HappyH and welcome to the the Lounge.

[Wicked Blue]

34. Peach

[debm55]

56. Yummy. I love peaches and peach ice cream would be wonderful. Thank you Wicked Blue.

[moniss]

35. Mackinac Island Fudge or

Plain Dark Chocolate and I used to eat Butter Brickle but it seems hard to find now around my area. Same with Maple ice cream. When I was a kid we could get Maple ice cream with a fudge sauce swirl or Maple with walnuts or brickle/toffee. Some brands have a toffee pieces ice cream but it is usually mixed with other things. Some of the brands when I was a kid had the brickle made so that it was a little less toffee/smoky flavor and it was a little softer as I recall.

[debm55]

57. Thank you very much, moniss. They sound wounderful.

[boonecreek]

36. Extreme Moose Tracks or

Stephen Colbert's Americone Dream.😋

[debm55]

61. Thank you boonecreek. I am going to give it a try.

[Paladin]

37. Blue Bell Bride's Cake.

Almond-flavored ice cream with small chunks of cake. Indecently good.

[debm55]

58. Oh how wonderful. Mouth is watering.

[Emile]

38. Caramel Praline Pecan Ice Cream

and Lemon Custard

[debm55]

53. My mouth is watering Emile. That sounds wounderful.Enjoy.

[bif]

39. Tillamook chocolate peanut butter

[debm55]

45. That sounds very good, bif. Enjoy

[debm55]

55. Yummy, bif. thank you sharing.

[LogDog75]

40. Chocolate

I do like to switch and go with Rocky Road or another flavor but I always come back to chocolate.

One flavor I liked, but can't find locally, is root beer flavored ice cream. My dad bought some from the Navy commissary back in the 90s and it was great.

[debm55]

46. Gee I never heard of root beer flavored ice cream. Hope you find it LogDog75

[Morbius]

41. VERY hard to find...

...and only available in harvest time.

I love pumpkin ice cream. Wonderful stuff.

[debm55]

44. Me too, Morbius. Yummy taste to go with the Fall

[beemerphill]

42. Mine is a Frozen Yogurt

Braums Cappuccino Chocolate Chunk

It is great in a bowl, but even better made into a malt.

[debm55]

43. Yummy, thank you beemerphill. That sounds delicious

[MIButterfly]

59. Cherry Garcia! With Stephen Colbert's Americone Dream a close second.

Love me some Ben & Jerry's! ❤️

I remember, as a kid, we always had butter pecan ice cream in the house. It was my grandmother's and uncle's favorite. I liked it too.

[debm55]

60. Great.Thank you MIButterfly for your wonderful choices.

[MIButterfly]

69. JMCKUSICK's mention of pistachio ice cream reminded me of how much I love spumoni!!

[JMCKUSICK]

62. Haagen Dazs Pistachio

Omg so yummy, and whole pistachios to boot.

[debm55]

65. Thank you ,John. Enjoy.

[MIButterfly]

68. I never knew Haagen-Dasz made pistachio ice cream. I'm going to have to look for it the next time I'm at Kroger.

[JMCKUSICK]

70. I love Haagen Dazs because

They have no crap in their ingredients.

[electric_blue68]

77. Ah. Will have to look for it esp bc it has whole pistachios on it!

[chowmama]

64. There are so many

For store-bought, New York Super Fudge Chocolate Chunk and Cherry Garcia.

In an ice cream parlor, I look for rum raisin, if they have it. Seasonally, pumpkin is good.

Homemade, Dreamsicle (vanilla mixed with OJ concentrate). The same trick works well with pineapple juice concentrate and I suppose I'll have to try limeade concentrate sometime.

[debm55]

67. Thank you very much chowmama. They all sound fabulous.

[electric_blue68]

72. Did someone mention Ice Cream?!!! 😄🥰....

Last edited Thu May 22, 2025, 11:18 AM - Edit history (1)

My top two brands
•Ben & Jerry's: Chocolate Therapy,
New York Super Fudge Chunk
•Talenti's [yes, it's Gelato, but...]:
Double Dark Chocolate. Omg! Dark Chocolate, with these little flecks of intense dark chocolate chips! Woah! And a bit of vermoth

Then...
•Baskin Robin's: Jamoca Almond Fudge
•Hagen Das: Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Butter Pecan, vanilla w fudge covered almonds

☆On family vacations around NYS, and New England we'd always looked for the local ice cream. Fun!

[debm55]

80. Thank you very much electric_blue68 for sharing all your favorites.

[Littlered]

76. Mint chocolate chip.

Ltely I’ve been on a Yasso mint chocolate chip kick for dessert.

[subterranean]

78. I've often wondered, why is there no mint ice cream without chocolate chips?

Maybe I'm in the minority, but I enjoy the cool mint flavor much more than the chocolate chips, which I could do without. If someone made just plain mint ice cream, I would totally buy that!

[debm55]

79. Thank you very much, Littlered. Enjoy

[ProfessorGAC]

81. Butter Pecan Here Too

But, back in the Baskin-Robbins days, I loved the pistachio almond & the daiquiri ice.
I know it's a weird combination, but I'd get one scoop of each.
Butter pecan is my favorite that I can get anywhere.

[debm55]

82. Thank you ProfessorGAC. Enjoy.

[Xavier Breath]

83. Graeter's Black Raspberry Chip.

Many companies make a black raspberry chip, but they a pale in comparison with Graeter's.

[Mad_Dem_X]

84. Chocolate Chip

[sakabatou]

85. Gold Medal Ribbon

[dai13sy]

86. Tillamook Peaches and Cream - makes me soooo happy

[wyn borkins]

87. Baskin-Robbins Pralines 'n Cream

[La Coliniere]

88. Wegman's Almond Milk Raspberry-Lemon

or SoDelicious’s Cashew Milk Snickerdoodle

[ailsagirl]

89. Good old chocolate