2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumI believe Trump like I believed Obama! A case study of 2 working-class Latino T voters: my parents
(note: I'm not the author of the article, not talking about my parents)
http://nonsite.org/editorial/i-believe-trump-like-i-believed-obama
By Leslie Lopez (University of Hawai‘i – West O‘ahu)
Christian Parenti’s Listening to Trump resonated with me on a personal level. Both of my “Latino” working-class parents voted for Trump, and I don’t think we were the only family politically divided this Thanksgiving.
snip....
Dad’s rationale for voting for Trump is that he genuinely has faith in the working class. “If you can finally manage to get a decent paying job, without having to work two or three jobs…once workers get good paying jobs, I really feel that workers will organize to protect their own safety, health, and environment.”
When I ask how he could have voted for someone, who in my view is the epitome of everything he has fought against his whole life, and how he could believe Trump’s promises, he says, “I believe Trump like I believed Obama!” Dad voted for Obama, twice. In 2009, when Obama emerged from the meeting with bankers and said, “I am the only one standing between you and the pitchforks,” we noticed when he didn’t side with the pitchforks. In 2010, when Obama applauded the mass firing of Rhode Island teachers—even I thought we were in trouble.
Before the election, Linda Tirado (2016) wrote about Trump, “Many people are uncomfortable with a lot of the stuff they’ve heard about him but accept it as a necessary evil: the main thing is to tell Washington elites that they’re not safe in their sinecures any more, that the common man is about to have his day.” She also says that Trump is the “Rorschach test of America’s fears”. I’m not sure if my father’s vote represented an elitist spanking and I wouldn’t presume to speak for him, still, this angle seems too self-indulgent and not his style. As far as I can tell Dad didn’t vote based on fear. He saw a way out of neoliberalism—a back-door strategy for the middle class, and banked on the hope that the self-admitted swindler might make good on his promise to be a class traitor. For him, the choice was between more neoliberalism, or a possible out from a celebrity and ruling class traitor.
snip....
It might be a huge stretch for some anti-racists to view Trump voters as something other than “deplorables,” or, rich, white, racists—but, the hope with this case study is that we might stop and reflect on who gains when we write off not just half the country but a large portion of the working class as racists.
Much more at the link, it's worth reading the whole thing.
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
LenaBaby61
(6,991 posts)This man may not be a racist, but at the very LEAST he's been bamboozled by tRumputin. I could say something else about him, but it's too early in the morning to get my blood pressure up and going off on him.
brush
(60,826 posts)
emulatorloo
(46,081 posts)Arazi
(8,232 posts)realmirage
(2,117 posts)If we offer more of the same uninspiring centrism (corporate friendly), we'll be permanent losers in elections
dionysus
(26,467 posts)Adrahil
(13,340 posts)Trump just won by lying.
We tried to win with offering people actual solutions. A significant portion of the voters just wanted to be lied to, or rather wanted to believe the lies.
okieinpain
(9,397 posts)make me want to vomit
"Dad’s rationale for voting for Trump is that he genuinely has faith in the working class. “If you can finally manage to get a decent paying job, without having to work two or three jobs…once workers get good paying jobs, I really feel that workers will organize to protect their own safety, health, and environment.” "
man the stupid in thinking like that is unfathomable.
Adrahil
(13,340 posts)
burrowowl
(18,328 posts)JI7
(92,371 posts)got more lower income working class voters also.
Trump voters tend to have more money.