Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: Peace [View all]

Solly Mack

(96,484 posts)
1. The scary part of non-violence is you can be killed. Non-violence pisses authority figures off to no end.
Mon Jan 12, 2026, 05:53 PM
Jan 12

I marched with Corretta Scott King and other well-known civil rights activists in Forsyth Country, Georgia (1987) and a gang of white men in a car tried to run me down. This was after the march and on my way back to my ride home. A black man, walking with a group of protesters enroute to the buses, saw what was happening and grabbed me out of the road. Literally saved my life.

Of course, regardless how you choose to protest, you can get killed when you're going against authoritarians - and angry white supremacists bow up with a quickness to what they see as a challenge to their dominance. They do tend to be cowards, though - if they know they aren't the only ones with weapons.

Still, there's an unspoken but keenly felt knowledge in non-violence (which includes civil disobedience) that you go unprotected. You go opening yourself up to the violence of others. It's expected. Relief when it doesn't happen, but you don't go thinking it can't happen because it can.

I was willing to risk it. Still am - but not everyone is. Not everyone sees the victory in it because pain and suffering, and possibly death, ain't exactly selling points.

Unfortunately, it's the images of violence directed at the peaceful that drives the point home that change has to happen. A change has to come.

It exposes the haters, the authoritarians for exactly who they are. Bullies. Cowards. Just plain bad people doing bad things.

Oh, some (and one person cheering is one too many) will cheer protesters being attacked, even killed, on national T.V./streaming on all formats - but most won't.

P.S. I'm OK with well plotted civil disobedience too.

Recommendations

9 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Peace [View all] H2O Man Jan 12 OP
The scary part of non-violence is you can be killed. Non-violence pisses authority figures off to no end. Solly Mack Jan 12 #1
Yes, you are right. H2O Man Jan 12 #5
Malcolm was right. Either way, you can still end up maimed or dead. Solly Mack Jan 12 #6
I agree 100% Non-Violent Protests is the ONLY Way forward. Nictuku Jan 12 #2
Than you! H2O Man Jan 12 #10
Thank you for this post H2O Man. I needed to livetohike Jan 12 #3
Thank you. H2O Man Jan 12 #11
... OneGrassRoot Jan 12 #4
I will need to H2O Man Jan 12 #12
YouTube it is! Thx. 💜 OneGrassRoot Jan 12 #15
A few years ago, H2O Man Jan 12 #18
Non-violence didn't work against Hitler. At all. SamuelTheThird Jan 12 #7
Respectfully disagree. H2O Man Jan 12 #14
I guess I wasn't clear SamuelTheThird Jan 12 #20
You were clear. H2O Man Jan 12 #22
Miller et al are only interested in violence in Democratic led cities and states malaise Jan 12 #8
I think that is Exactly It Malaise Nictuku Jan 12 #13
Do you think if people are 100% non-violent Trump will just go 'oh well' SamuelTheThird Jan 12 #21
"They're eating dogs! H2O Man Jan 12 #16
You always give us hope malaise Jan 12 #19
Thanks...K&R spanone Jan 12 #9
Thank you! H2O Man Jan 12 #17
Amen. Those days are the American legacy that we must live by and live up to. ancianita Jan 12 #23
Thank you! H2O Man Jan 12 #24
Violence is the last resort of the incompetent BeneteauBum Jan 12 #25
Right. H2O Man Jan 12 #29
When has stumpy, Prairie_Seagull Jan 12 #26
Exactly. H2O Man Jan 12 #30
Well said Saoirse9 Jan 12 #27
Be patient. H2O Man Jan 12 #31
Never been more grateful for Saoirse9 Jan 12 #28
As you know, H2O Man Jan 12 #32
Wise words Saoirse9 Jan 13 #41
I hear you! H2O Man Jan 13 #42
Non violence is sometimes necessary when you are powerless Keepthesoulalive Jan 12 #33
"Whose blood"? H2O Man Jan 12 #34
It has always been our blood Keepthesoulalive Jan 12 #35
It is important H2O Man Jan 12 #36
You did not live in the city. Keepthesoulalive Jan 13 #37
Ha! H2O Man Jan 13 #38
The proven effectiveness of Dr. King's method cannot be denied Martin Eden Jan 13 #39
Exactly! H2O Man Jan 13 #40
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Peace»Reply #1