Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

kst

(75 posts)
36. No, that's not how impeachment works
Tue Feb 24, 2026, 08:28 PM
Tuesday

"If Nixon had been impeached Gerald Ford his VP would also be out of office."

That's incorrect. If Nixon had been impeached and convicted, he would have been removed from office and Gerald Ford would have become President.

Article II, Section 4 of the Constitution says:

The President, Vice President and all civil Officers of the United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.


Some people have misinterpreted the word "all" to imply that removing a President automatically removes the entire administration. What it really means is that the President, Vice President, and all civil officers are potentially subject to impeachment, conviction, and removal. Each impeachment proceeding applies to one and only one person.

Only the individual person who is convicted is removed from office.

Perhaps "each" would have been clearer than "all". But think about it logically. Would the authors of the Constitution really have wanted an entire administration to be automatically removed due to high crimes and misdemeanors committed by one person? That would have been absurd -- and if it had been the intent, it would have been expressed more clearly.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Not literally, I hope. Thry'd need a rush job to get the carpets cleaned. NT mahatmakanejeeves Tuesday #1
that may happen at tonight's to-do barbtries Tuesday #8
Sadly not literally. Buzz cook Tuesday #29
Why the Democrats HAVE to Control Congress.. homegirl Tuesday #23
"If Nixon had been impeached Gerald Ford his VP would also be out of office." mahatmakanejeeves Tuesday #27
That's not true ITAL Tuesday #28
No, that's not how impeachment works kst Tuesday #36
This message was self-deleted by its author AllyCat Yesterday #39
Nah...Ford would not have been removed. Nixon resigned to keep his pension the Bengus81 Yesterday #41
Madam Speaker????? n/t Timewas Tuesday #2
Whoever happens to be presiding over the House at the time. NT mahatmakanejeeves Tuesday #3
Thank You Timewas Tuesday #32
Re: Thank You kst Tuesday #37
BRA EFFING VO Faux pas Tuesday #4
Please proceed, governor... Wednesdays Tuesday #5
Kicked and recommended Uncle Joe Tuesday #6
Most welcome orangecrush Tuesday #11
The glyphosate speech KT2000 Tuesday #7
Names usonian Tuesday #9
I get the feeling Massie is positioning himself to run for president. Gaugamela Tuesday #10
He is not naming Donald J. Trump. chowder66 Tuesday #12
who I might add has been mentioned over 1 million times in the epstein files Javaman Tuesday #13
Oops! He forgot to mention the guy whose name is in the files ten thousand times. Gary 50 Tuesday #14
Leon Black, Jess Staley, Leslie Wexner Renew Deal Tuesday #15
Amen and Halleluia. More of this from Congress. wnylib Tuesday #16
Uhhhhh..... SergeStorms Tuesday #17
I hear that Iran has a large gold and silver vault like Baghdad did. Rumors was that Venezuela had already shipped their LiberalArkie Tuesday #21
Trump would steal the stink off shit..... SergeStorms Tuesday #24
😂😂😂 Traildogbob Tuesday #30
He would crawl across broken glass and rizlaplus Yesterday #40
You give him too much credit. Woodwizard 22 hrs ago #42
How will homegirl Tuesday #25
Send ICE! orangecrush Tuesday #35
His plea about Round Up was good too.. nt Figarosmom Tuesday #18
Is this old news from December? I can't see the video becuase it demands I sign in but Wonder Why Tuesday #19
It shows "February 24, 2026" on the video muriel_volestrangler Tuesday #22
Thanks. I was just trying to confirm it. Wonder Why Tuesday #26
Hooray for Rep Massie. He spoke the truth forthright. Fla Dem Tuesday #20
That's good, but all 3 of those names have been publicly linked to Epstein and possibly his crimes for Wiz Imp Tuesday #31
More please Evolve Dammit Tuesday #33
PREACH IT BROTHER THOMAS Skittles Tuesday #34
This thing is coming to the surface fast. yellow dahlia Tuesday #38
Excellent speech. Martin68 21 hrs ago #43
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Thomas Massie explode on ...»Reply #36