Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

wnylib

(25,715 posts)
Mon Mar 9, 2026, 06:42 AM Yesterday

I am not a military strategist, but [View all]

if you plan to attack a country, don't you consider the risks and plan in advance how to reduce them?

Example, in an attack on Iran, it was predictable that the Strait of Hormuz would get blocked, leaving ships bottlenecked with repercussions around the world on oil supplies and other goods. The result of that is inflation and shortages.

So is there a way that the Strait of Hormuz could have been protected in advance of the bombing? If not, what about detouring ships to a safer route before bombing? That would be an inconvenience and extra cost for the ships and their cargo companies but it's costing them to sit still, too, and is creating shortages.

Wouldn't it have been prudent to protect our bases in Middle East countries against Iranian counter attacks prior to bombing Iran?

As I said, I am not a strategist. I have never been in the military although my father, 2 brothers, nephew, and cousin were. So maybe I'm misguided about advance planning and protections.







48 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The trouble is, Trump doesn't look at history, geography, political, science or anything Walleye Yesterday #1
He's Been Wanting To Attack IRAN Mr.Bee 21 hrs ago #38
But he is good buddies with the Saudi Walleye 19 hrs ago #42
Follow the money Tim S Yesterday #2
ALWAYS. OldBaldy1701E 22 hrs ago #28
I'm certain that a multitude of studies and reports from all branches of the Pentagon no_hypocrisy Yesterday #3
Trump's goal is to steal oil, land, cash, power. Irish_Dem Yesterday #4
Even Trump knows that he won't live much longer wnylib Yesterday #5
His mind is a very dark place, so I shudder to contemplate what he thinks. Joinfortmill 23 hrs ago #17
Yes, looking into the mind of a psychopath can be daunting. Irish_Dem 19 hrs ago #45
Remember that t-shirt/bumper sticker that said AllyCat 21 hrs ago #39
He wants to die the richest man on the planet. Irish_Dem 19 hrs ago #46
He thought Gaza and Venezuela were easy victories and he is a god. rubbersole Yesterday #8
There is no other way for tankers to leave the Persian Gulf genxlib Yesterday #6
No, the costs of war cannot be eliminated. David__77 Yesterday #7
Sounds to me that you gave this war more thought and insight than the morans who launched it Rhiannon12866 Yesterday #9
A dangerous mix of arrogance and ignorance malaise Yesterday #10
To take it further. Woodwizard 23 hrs ago #11
Wakeee Wakeee Snoopy 7 23 hrs ago #12
We must never forget... GiqueCee 23 hrs ago #13
Trump is incompetent by our standards but wnylib 22 hrs ago #33
And you know who REALLY benefits from the price of oil TexasBushwhacker 18 hrs ago #48
The least dumbass Trump could have done True Dough 23 hrs ago #14
Maybe that's why he took Venezuela's oil before bombing Iran. wnylib 23 hrs ago #18
You're right. They're dumber than rocks. Joinfortmill 23 hrs ago #15
You're thinking of a normal president not suffering from tertiary syphilis. Ray Bruns 23 hrs ago #16
Trump isn't trying to take over the Middle East. He is trying to take over the United States. hadEnuf 23 hrs ago #19
More than taking over the US. wnylib 22 hrs ago #23
Hard to say if the American people will go down without a fight. hadEnuf 22 hrs ago #30
As we recall, Rumsfeld ignored Deminpenn 22 hrs ago #20
I was never prouder of Rummy then when retold the reporters, "You go to war with the unknowns you have, not with the 3Hotdogs 22 hrs ago #22
Ask me about Hillbilly Armor on Humvees. James48 22 hrs ago #25
Sounds like the beginning of an interesting story, 3Hotdogs 22 hrs ago #26
Warriors don't worry about risks. AverageOldGuy 22 hrs ago #21
Then you've never been under the leadership..... lastlib 22 hrs ago #24
Trump doesn't consider all that shit. Turbineguy 22 hrs ago #27
I am a Desert Storm vereran Puppyjive 22 hrs ago #29
My nephew is a Desert Storm vet. He was in the Air Force Reserves wnylib 22 hrs ago #37
Krasnov went to war to show the world he could, on his own. gab13by13 22 hrs ago #31
Worse than Iraq Johnny2X2X 22 hrs ago #32
A week in and I'm still trying to figure out the actual goal of the operation Torchlight 22 hrs ago #34
Plan in advance? Such a quaint concept. We now live by the law of unintended consequences and spin spin spin. dutch777 22 hrs ago #35
He isn't, nor does he listen to them. Ferrets are Cool 22 hrs ago #36
Objective leaders consider risks and plan in advance to educe them. Bush and Trump both ignored this rule. Martin68 21 hrs ago #40
I have pondering Official Acts vs Criminal Acts. Dan 21 hrs ago #41
Could we say that attacking Iran was not an wnylib 19 hrs ago #44
Almost like it would have been easier not to attack Iran... 0rganism 19 hrs ago #43
I can guarantee attacking Iran has been regularly wargamed haele 19 hrs ago #47
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I am not a military strat...