Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

xocetaceans

(4,019 posts)
16. The part of the podcast interview that is mentioned in the article's headline is within a few of minutes of 22:17 in...
Mon Jan 13, 2025, 05:25 PM
Jan 13

...this video. The actual quote is shortly after 23:17, but starting at the earlier time index gives more context to the answer:



When Shulman talks about game theory and all of the players, it seems that he is really saying that his company should not be destroyed (i.e., it is all about his self-interest, not about giving people the joy of creating music).

It may seem alarmist, but the future of AI runs the risk of flooding the arts with insipid and uninspired trash in the form of boilerplate poetry, literature, and music. So much of that could be created at such a low cost and with such rapidity that it might nearly completely devalue the art that some artists are struggling to make and from which they also hope to make a living. People have a limited capacity to experience music and other arts: if all potential listeners are overwhelmed by AI-generated trash, that might be another way in which human art may be destroyed and displaced. This seems to be headed in the same direction as Lyft/Uber/Airbnb in that some people have decided that there is a market to disrupt and that they should be the ones to profit from the destruction of whatever conventions currently apply in it. It might not be enough to prevent the flooding and saturation of the art world, but perhaps no AI-generated object should be granted any form of IP rights: that might be enough to take the profit out of endeavors such as Shulman's.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Playing music is already a super power. May become a rarer super power. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Jan 13 #1
No, it's not a "super power" maxsolomon Jan 14 #23
Everyone can learn cursive handwriting. Yet now, it is a superpower boomers use to impress youngsters Bernardo de La Paz Jan 14 #24
Misleading headline. speak easy Jan 13 #2
No, it isn't. If the headline had read "No one ever enjoys making music" it would have been highplainsdem Jan 13 #4
Nope. speak easy Jan 13 #9
This message was self-deleted by its author speak easy Jan 13 #6
Creating music; poetry; art is at the center of human existence... EarthFirst Jan 13 #3
I feel like this will eventually lead to a renaissance of the live performance. bullimiami Jan 13 #5
Stupid little manchild Clouds Passing Jan 13 #7
As my stomach churns Lulu KC Jan 13 #8
Bullshit. Basso8vb Jan 13 #10
He lost me at, "I think..." (n/t) PJMcK Jan 13 #11
If you're using AI to "make music" you're not making music. CaptainTruth Jan 13 #12
My analogy is a homeowner who has great landscaping. Igel Jan 13 #19
That's a great analogy. CaptainTruth Jan 13 #22
... says a person who doesn't make music. JoseBalow Jan 13 #13
Creating something worthwhile isn't SUPPOSED to be "fun" Rocknation Jan 13 #14
Or perhaps AI is... xocetaceans Jan 13 #17
He is so full of s-it FakeNoose Jan 13 #15
The part of the podcast interview that is mentioned in the article's headline is within a few of minutes of 22:17 in... xocetaceans Jan 13 #16
Ah, what even I would call "flooding the zone" with, um, yeah. n/t Igel Jan 13 #20
"...the future of AI runs the risk of flooding the arts with insipid and uninspired trash..." LudwigPastorius Jan 13 #21
AI is cancer Blue_Tires Jan 13 #18
Agree IA8IT Jan 14 #27
As a Visual Artist: I -often enjoy- my Art Making, as well as the Results... electric_blue68 Jan 14 #25
I'm sure Elton John just hated composing music. Mosby Jan 14 #26
There's magic in the creative process, whether it be music, literature, art, design, or any other creative expression. patphil Jan 14 #28
What a fucking MORAN!!!! /NT sdfernando Jan 14 #29
Does he know any people? chowmama Jan 14 #30
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»CEO of AI Music Company S...»Reply #16