Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Fiction

Showing Original Post only (View all)

hippywife

(22,767 posts)
Sat Feb 12, 2022, 12:09 PM Feb 2022

Historical Fiction Frustrations. [View all]

Historical fiction is my favorite genre. Over the years, I've read every one that James Michener wrote, as well as all of Margaret George's books and a few of Michelle Moran's, all of Wendell Berry's Port William Series, Ivan Doig's Two Medicine Trilogy, as well as others he's written, and Ken Follet's Knightsbridge Series. These are the kind of reads I really love! (I read all of Jane Auel's Earth's Children series, but could have done without the last couple or so, for reasons below.)

I'm struggling now to find really well written historical fiction. When I look at the offerings on Libby in particular, but also other lists, they throw all kinds of bodice rippers into that category, so many that they seem the majority. I feel they should be listed as romance novels or a new genre developed, such as period dramas or something of that nature. I despise romance novels, as well as any books where the romance between the main characters is either the focus of the story or central to the plot.

I recently found and read Jane Smiley's trilogy The Last Hundred Years: A Family Saga, which I enjoyed very much. Last night, I started re-reading Lonesome Dove. I first read it when it originally came out in paperback and I now want to read the series, so thought I should re-read LD first since it's been so long.

Anyone else experiencing this frustration or have any recommendations for really good historical fiction (excluding Shogun or anything like it, or any where war is the primary focus.) Thanks for any help in this area.

ETA: I've also read all of Colleen McCullough's Masters of Rome Series. Can't believe I forgot that one!

ETA2: Have also read a few of Edward Rutherfurd's books, too.

34 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Historical Fiction Frustrations. [View all] hippywife Feb 2022 OP
Agree! RockCreek Feb 2022 #1
I'm not entirely sure Diamond_Dog Feb 2022 #2
That might be interesting. Thanks! nt hippywife Feb 2022 #19
Colleen McCullough's Masters of Rome series was excellent eShirl Feb 2022 #3
I can't believe I forgot that one! hippywife Feb 2022 #6
Excellent series kimbutgar Feb 2022 #23
Bernard Cornwell has a lot -- a LOT- of well-researched historical series viva la Feb 2022 #4
A lot of them, including Michener hippywife Feb 2022 #9
That's the problem with British historical fiction... viva la Feb 2022 #15
The Name of the Rose by Umberto Eco, One Hundred Years of Solitude Ocelot II Feb 2022 #5
I've read Wolf Hall hippywife Feb 2022 #8
But at least they're not romance novels! Ocelot II Feb 2022 #11
Wolf Hall is wonderful-- viva la Feb 2022 #18
Just read The Silence of the Girls and was pleasantly surprised despite the weird title. Scrivener7 Feb 2022 #7
Thanks, I'll check it out. nt hippywife Feb 2022 #12
I love The Circle of Ceridwen series for its historical vanlassie Feb 2022 #10
Thanks for the rec. hippywife Feb 2022 #13
Yea, it's not, actually. vanlassie Feb 2022 #24
That was the impression I got hippywife Feb 2022 #26
I totally agree! CrispyQ Feb 2022 #14
I'd be against hippywife Feb 2022 #16
They're old, but Jilly_in_VA Feb 2022 #17
How about Edward Rutherford? He does big fabulous books Scrivener7 Feb 2022 #20
Thanks, hippywife Feb 2022 #21
Have you read any Gary Jennings books? kimbutgar Feb 2022 #22
Yes, I read Aztec because a friend sent it to me after she finished. hippywife Feb 2022 #25
Good stuff! madamesilverspurs Feb 2022 #27
I've re-read a few of Michener's. hippywife Feb 2022 #30
You could try Dorothy Dunnett... malthaussen Feb 2022 #28
WWII, WESTERN werdna Feb 2022 #29
I love good historical fiction I just re-read, The Little Book, Selden Edwards, have you read it? ShazamIam Feb 2022 #31
Here are some authors that I like quite a bit. You might enjoy some of them. japple Feb 2022 #32
Thank you. hippywife Feb 2022 #33
The Bookwoman of Troublesome Creek - about the blue people of Kentucky. patricia92243 Sep 2022 #34
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Fiction»Historical Fiction Frustr...»Reply #0