Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

hippywife

(22,767 posts)
29. This was a pretty good read.
Sat Apr 11, 2015, 06:47 PM
Apr 2015

It's written in what was mostly a lot of poor grammar, the main characters being largely uneducated outside of their churches, so that took a little getting used to in the beginning, but wasn't a lot of work to read, or terribly difficult to overcome so that it took away from enjoying the story.

It did turn out to be pretty heavy on doctrine, and the differences/fissures between the various sects of American religion at the time. I suppose she was trying to make it as intrinsic to the story as possible, and it was to some extent, but I didn't think it needed to be as heavy on that aspect (I skipped over a few of the excerpts of the sermons given by the main character's Calvinist preacher husband.). It was basically almost all they talked about, lived and breathed, colored most of the story, as they were pretty insular for the most part. There was a major good vs. evil thread that ran throughout, doctrinally, as well as the major plot line, and interwoven through both, but not as tightly as it might have been.

I still liked the main character, though she and the other female characters didn't think much of themselves or their contribution to the lives of their families and the hardships they endured without every dropping the domestic ball. They worked really hard from sun-up to sundown, but were just wives and mothers, nothing more even in their own eyes. Her husband was pretty likeable, as well. Not a fire and brimstone style preacher, but a seemingly reasonable man who was kind and loving to his wife, his kids and the people around him, even the very divisive and annoying among them.

It was a pretty quick easy read, and the story line itself held my interest throughout, with the settlers moving ever west from Kentucky through Missouri, and all the conflicts that caused. Was pretty light on the details of the major happenings of the times. Much of it was mentioned mostly in passing with the characters discussing it and wondering how it would impact their lives, without actually going very deeply into how it would or did. Was heavy on the interactions, both positive and negative, with the Native Americans ("Injuns" to one and all), and surviving the seismic upheavals along the New Madrid fault.

Anyone who likes very light historical fiction, heavy on the family, community and religious lives of the settlers, but light on historic details, would probably enjoy it.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Hello, everyone! Thank you for the thread, scarletwoman. Happy Easter! Chocolate bunnies! Enthusiast Apr 2015 #1
I've probably read The Source hippywife Apr 2015 #6
I agree with your take on Michener. I read The Covenant and Space years ago. Enthusiast Apr 2015 #11
Poland hippywife Apr 2015 #13
Thank you. Enthusiast Apr 2015 #15
Cute. :0) eom hippywife Apr 2015 #16
Hi, Enthusiast! I'm sure you'll live long enough to read all of Rankin - I did it in a few months. scarletwoman Apr 2015 #8
We are nearly finished with the James D. Doss books. I will be sad when they end. Enthusiast Apr 2015 #12
Truthfully, I'm good with taking a pass on Michener. scarletwoman Apr 2015 #18
I will certainly keep the Rostnikov books in mind. Enthusiast Apr 2015 #19
"Detective Inspector Huss," Helene Tursten shenmue Apr 2015 #2
That sounds fun. Motorcycle gang....... Enthusiast Apr 2015 #3
Despite my prediliction for Nordic Noir, I have continued to hesitate over Helene Tursten. scarletwoman Apr 2015 #9
Happy Easter, fellow readers. hermetic Apr 2015 #4
Hi, hermetic! Thank you for posting. scarletwoman Apr 2015 #10
Thank YOU, scarletwoman hermetic Apr 2015 #25
Dear hermetic, it's delightful to have you here in the Fiction group! scarletwoman Apr 2015 #26
Annamanda by Jo Houser Haring hippywife Apr 2015 #5
I did a little google, too. scarletwoman Apr 2015 #7
Thanks, Scarletwoman... hippywife Apr 2015 #14
It actually sounds like a very interesting book. scarletwoman Apr 2015 #17
I'm almost throught he first 100 pages hippywife Apr 2015 #20
This was a pretty good read. hippywife Apr 2015 #29
Excllent review! scarletwoman Apr 2015 #30
You're very welcome, sw. hippywife Apr 2015 #31
Well, I have to say, yours was a professional quality review. scarletwoman Apr 2015 #32
Dandelion Wine by Ray Bradbury Number9Dream Apr 2015 #21
How lovely! Bradbury was a wonderful writer, well worth re-reading! scarletwoman Apr 2015 #23
Brief review of "Dandelion Wine" Number9Dream Apr 2015 #27
Bravo! Thank you for sharing your lovely review on this thread! scarletwoman Apr 2015 #28
Thank you, Number9Dream. Enthusiast Apr 2015 #33
Emily St. John Mandel's book, Station Eleven. It is very, very good. japple Apr 2015 #22
That's cool. I checked back and it was SheilaT who first mentioned that book on the March 8 thread. scarletwoman Apr 2015 #24
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Fiction»What are you reading the ...»Reply #29