Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

freeplessinseattle

(3,508 posts)
Sat Dec 31, 2011, 12:59 PM Dec 2011

My friend's young daughter passed away from leukemia recently and she is mad at God [View all]

Any advice for what I can say to help even a little bit that wouldn't accidentally be offensive and would resonate with her on her level? I am having a hard enough time as it is trying to think of the right things to say to help, and sure wish I had finished my darn Master's in counseling because I am feeling completely incompetent.

While I know that nothing I say can really ease the pain much at all, I feel like a useless dummy just repeating how sorry I am, especially when she said she is tired of people's condolences. I've suggested she go to grief counseling, but I think she is feeling too paralyzed to do anything.

I have no religious background but she is a devout Mormon and strongly believed that if she had enough faith her daughter would be ok, so now thinks that she didn't have enough faith, or did something to disappoint God so he let her down.

While I can see how the idea of faith can help provide comfort and strength in trying times, much like the power of positive thinking, I can't help but feel it is deceptive and messes with people's minds too much to encourage people to put so much faith in the power of God.

I don't want to say what I really think, that if God is so all powerful why does cancer, especially childhood leukemia, exist in the first place? And why does he/she need such constant validation of other's faith and approval in order to help? Seems a little narcisstic to me (but of course I would never say that).

Right now I am sure she is feeling angry and confused, and needs a target for her anger, so God is handy. Since her religion gave her comfort before though and nothing else really can right now I think it would be helpful if I can somehow get her back on track to finding some comfort in her faith still, and a suitable explanationdespite being "let down" Maybe something like saying that some things are more powerful than God, but he tried, and is still all loving, etc...or...??

26 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
What I appreciated the most... OneGrassRoot Dec 2011 #1
I do get that, but simply remaining silent while she is pouring her heart out freeplessinseattle Dec 2011 #2
I don't have insight about the religious aspect... OneGrassRoot Dec 2011 #4
Thank you, it does help to know that simply being silent isn't necessarily freeplessinseattle Dec 2011 #9
Comforting doesn't necessarily mean advice-giving Remember Me Dec 2011 #15
i'm of the same mind as OGR. Howler Dec 2011 #3
Thank you. I guess i just feel that if I remain silent freeplessinseattle Dec 2011 #6
maybe she feels more comfortable telling you that WolverineDG Dec 2011 #12
Whoa ! Whoa! Whoa! Howler Dec 2011 #19
I agree with OGR and Howler Tumbulu Dec 2011 #5
Thank you, that is a good idea, I will ponder on some ideas freeplessinseattle Dec 2011 #7
Perhaps ask what she needs and listen Matariki Dec 2011 #8
she says she wants to try to process things but doesn't know how freeplessinseattle Dec 2011 #10
Yeah, that's really really tough Matariki Dec 2011 #13
Thank you Matariki! and get this, her daughter was signed up for a promising study freeplessinseattle Dec 2011 #16
Probably the worst thing given to my dad & me when my mom died was WolverineDG Dec 2011 #11
After my dad died when I was a kid rosesaylavee Dec 2011 #14
Be her friend. BlueToTheBone Dec 2011 #17
Grieving PADemD Dec 2011 #18
You know Freepless, I'm dealing with cancer as we speak and I just got home from watching Ecumenist Jan 2012 #20
I'm so sorry to hear that. Cleita Jan 2012 #22
Thank you Cleita!! Ecumenist Jan 2012 #25
what ecumenist said magical thyme Jan 2012 #23
If you stop believing in God, then there is no one to blame would be a cynic's answer. Cleita Jan 2012 #21
Well Said, Cleita! Ecumenist Jan 2012 #24
Here's my two cents. SheilaT Jan 2012 #26
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Astrology, Spirituality & Alternative Healing»My friend's young daughte...»Reply #0